
Tucked into a small strip mall on Shelby Road in Shelby Township, Eataliana Homemade Pasta looks like an easy place to drive past, but Michigan pasta lovers know better. 🍝
Yelp just ranked it No. 2 on its Top 100 Pasta Places of 2026, second only to a pasta shop in New Jersey on a national list of trattorias, pasta shops and markets. 🏆
Every pasta is made fresh by hand each day and paired with slow-simmered homemade sauces, and you can eat in, take out or bring home fresh pasta to cook yourself.
Best of all, the couple behind it brought their recipes straight from Rome, along with a dream of sharing a true Italian Sunday lunch. ❤️

How Eataliana won Shelby Township’s hearts
Eleonora and Mihail Dumitru made the journey from Rome to Michigan with their two children, choosing Shelby Township after visiting Eleonora’s parents, who had already settled there.
Their dream was to share the warmth of the Italian Sunday lunch, a meal they describe as being about family and togetherness as much as the food on the table. 🇮🇹
To get started, the couple brought pasta machines over from Italy, and a chef came along for three weeks to set up the equipment and work with them until everything was just right.

Today, every batch of dough is still mixed, rolled and shaped by hand, while the sauces are slow-cooked with ripe tomatoes, fragrant herbs and carefully chosen spices.
The two bestselling sauces are the creamy tomato Salsa Rosa and the Vodka & Prosciutto Cotto, a rosy vodka sauce made with Italian cooked ham. 🍅
The shop also works like a little Italian market, selling fresh pasta in bulk with cooking instructions, plus homemade sauces to take home for dinner.

On Sundays, when the dining room is closed, Eleonora and Mihail lead hands-on pasta-making classes where guests knead dough, cut fettuccine and ravioli and cook their own sauces. 👩🍳
The praise has been building for years: Eat This, Not That! once named it Michigan’s No. 1 Italian restaurant, and its meaty house lasagna made Yelp’s Top 20 Spots for Lasagna list.
Then came the national pasta ranking in October 2026, released ahead of National Pasta Day, and its Yelp listing now shows 4.8 stars from more than 430 reviews and a 97 out of 100 health score.

One Yelp reviewer summed up the appeal after a plate of seasonal pumpkin ravioli with butter and sage: everything is scratch-made, and the pumpkin was fresh, not canned. 🎃
Taken together, a family from Rome, pasta rolled by hand every day and recipes made for sharing explain why Shelby Township treats this tiny shop like its own Italian kitchen.
Food Highlights

- Lasagna: Layers of fresh pasta smothered in Salsa-Mia, a sauce of Italian sausage, ground beef, tomato and wine, with creamy béchamel, mozzarella and parmigiano reggiano. One regular says a single generous portion easily stretches into two meals. 🧀
- Four Cheese Ravioli: Fresh ravioli stuffed with asiago, fontina, ricotta and parmigiano, served with your choice of pesto, butter sage, marinara, Alfredo or the spicy “angry” arrabbiata sauce for a little extra heat. 🌶️
- Sunflower Ravioli: Round ravioli filled with prosciutto, grana padano and ricotta, finished in a silky butter sage sauce. One regular who has taken two of the couple’s cooking classes calls it her favorite dish on the menu. 🌻

- Square Ravioli: Square-cut pasta stuffed with wine-braised beef and pork, carrots, celery and onion, then paired with the creamy tomato Salsa Rosa, one of the kitchen’s two bestselling sauces. Hearty, homey comfort food. 🥩
- Pappardelle: Broad, flat ribbons of fresh pasta tossed in a creamy mushroom sauce with Italian sausage, onion and olive oil. One Yelp reviewer captioned a photo of this dish with a simple “OMG! Good!” 🍄
- Seafood Ravioli: Ravioli filled with shrimp and salmon, sautéed in brandy and served with Salsa Rosa and a spoonful of ricotta, a richer pick for anyone who wants something beyond the classic red-sauce dishes. 🦐
- Tiramisu: Eleonora’s homemade tiramisu layers mascarpone custard, coffee-soaked ladyfingers and cocoa, and there is a fruit version too. Every pasta plate already comes with a side salad and a roll, so save room. 🍰

Atmosphere
This is a small, casual spot, with only four booths inside and a few tables outdoors in warmer weather, so Yelpers recommend arriving early or joining the crowd ordering takeout. 🪑
Reviewers describe the room as quiet and good for kids, and many mention friendly chats with the owners themselves, who seem happy to make sure every plate comes out just right. 🌿

Bottom Line
Visit for pasta rolled by hand every day, a Top 20 lasagna and a warm welcome from a family that brought its recipes from Rome to Shelby Township.
Hours are limited, from 3 to 8 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. on Friday and Saturday, so call ahead for one of the four booths or order carry-out and take a bag of fresh pasta home for later.
Planning more stops nearby? See our other Michigan restaurant picks.
Address: 52901 Shelby Rd, Shelby Township, MI 48316
📞 (586) 580-2136
🕔 Tue–Thu 3PM–8PM, Fri–Sat 11AM–8PM (Closed Sun–Mon)
