
Today is National Cat Day. So we went looking for the places in America where cats are the stars.
Our favorite is a writer’s house in Key West, where nearly 60 cats rule the garden. Many of them have six toes.
Hemingway’s six-toed cats
Ernest Hemingway lived at 907 Whitehead Street in Key West from 1931 to 1938, a federal appeals court noted in a case about the cats.
A ship’s captain, Stanley Dexter, had a white six-toed cat named Snowball. Dexter gave Hemingway one of her kittens, Snow White, Garden & Gun reported.
Today the museum is home to nearly 60 polydactyl cats, the Hemingway Home says. About half show the extra toes, but they all carry the gene.
Bernice Dixon bought the house from Hemingway’s estate in 1961 and opened it for tours in 1964, the court noted. The cats roam freely inside the brick wall, and the museum gives them weekly vet care.
Mittens, luck and a tidy colony
Polydactyl cats are not a breed. The trait can show up in tabbies, calicos, black or white cats, the museum explains. Some paws look like they wear mittens.
Sailors thought these cats brought luck, and they were good hunters on ships, PR director Alexa Morgan told Garden & Gun.
The colony stays at about 60. Most cats are spayed or neutered, and one couple a year may have a litter, Morgan said.
Hemingway was “very accident-prone,” Morgan said, so the lucky six-toed cats suited him well.
Related:
7 of the Best Breakfast Spots in Key West, Florida
3 Special Hole in the Wall Restaurants in Key West, Florida
Walk the house with the cats
Tickets include a 20 to 30 minute guided tour. Tours start every 15 minutes, the first at 9:15 a.m., the museum says.
Cats sleep on the beds and stroll the gardens. Let them come to you.
Cat World, in the Utah red rocks
Best Friends Animal Sanctuary in Kanab, Utah, is the largest sanctuary of its kind in the U.S. It spans nearly 5,800 acres in Angel Canyon.
Its Cat World is home to more than 600 rescued cats in 11 buildings. Each has indoor rooms and enclosed outdoor “catios.”
Cat World tours run Sundays, Mondays and Tuesdays at 1:30 p.m. They last about 90 minutes and cover a mile of sand and uneven ground.
More than 30,000 people visit the Sanctuary each year. It sits near Zion National Park, the Grand Canyon’s North Rim, Bryce Canyon and Lake Powell, Best Friends notes, so it fits easily into a southwest road trip.
No tour time? Club Sinjin at Cat World and Roxy’s Room by the Welcome Center are open daily for drop-in visits with adoptable cats, Best Friends says.
Related:
2 Truly Fantastic Hidden Gems to Experience in Utah
A whole museum for the house cat
In the North Carolina mountains, the American Museum of the House Cat in Sylva fills its rooms with cat art, toys and history.
The late Dr. Harold Sims, known locally as “Cat Man,” founded it in 2017, WJLA’s Amazing America reported. It even holds a mummified medieval cat.
Admission helps fund the Catman2 shelter, a cats-only, cage-free sanctuary nearby, the museum says.
The museum moved to its permanent home and reopened in spring 2023, its website says. Before that, it welcomed over 18,000 guests from 2017 to 2019.
It is open every day except Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day and New Year’s Day. A $25 curated tour is available by appointment, the museum says.
Related:
Best Things to Do in Asheville, NC: Your Ultimate Guide
A little history: the Siamese comes to America
The Hemingway cats are polydactyl, not Siamese. But the Siamese has its own American story.
On November 1, 1878, U.S. consul David B. Sickels wrote from Bangkok to First Lady Lucy Hayes about a gift: a Siamese cat named Siam. The letter is held by the Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Center.
Siam arrived in 1879, one of the first Siamese cats in the United States, and became the pet of daughter Fanny, the National Archives notes. She died about nine months later.
Legend says Siamese cats once guarded temples in old Siam. It is a lovely tale, but only a tale.
Before you go
Where do I park?
The Hemingway Home has no parking lot of its own. Metered street parking nearby is often full, so walking or biking is easier, Key West Vacation Center advises. Sylva’s cat museum has a free lot next door, WJLA reported.
When is the best time to go?
The Hemingway Home opens daily at 9 a.m. Come early for the first tour at 9:15, when the cats are out and the garden is cool.
How much does it cost?
Hemingway Home: $19 adults, $7 ages 6 to 12, free for 5 and under, plus a 3% card fee. Cat museum: $10 adults, $5 ages 6 to 12. Best Friends tours are free.
Do I need reservations?
Not at the Hemingway Home; tickets are sold only at the gate. At Best Friends, book tours and volunteer shifts ahead, because walk-ins are not allowed in animal areas.
Go say hello to a six-toed legend.
The Hemingway Home on Google Street View
Happy National Cat Day, from our cats to yours, and from Scarlight X.

