
Milwaukee’s Transfer Pizzeria Café has a backstory with more layers than its cheese-covered pizzas, beginning inside a corner building once occupied by a neighborhood pharmacy.
The restaurant opened in March 2008, transforming a former diner into a gathering place with personality to spare.
Its name honors Transfer Pharmacy and the commuters who changed streetcars and buses outside.
Today, that neighborhood connection continues through imaginative pizzas, preserved architectural details, and live music that gives dinner its own distinctly Milwaukee soundtrack.

How Transfer Pizzeria Café won Mitchell ’s hearts
Transfer began with an intriguing partnership: two first-generation Italian-American brothers, a Polish-German immigrant, and a Ukrainian pizza maker, all bringing different backgrounds to the same neighborhood table.
Before customers could grab their first slices, the Rossettos spent nearly two years restoring the former diner, uncovering tilework, woodwork, and stained glass hidden beneath decades of alterations.
Instead of scrubbing away the building’s history, they gave those discoveries another turn in the spotlight, creating a restaurant with character that no decorating catalog could supply.

The name carried that thinking further, preserving memories of the old pharmacy and the intersection where Milwaukee commuters once transferred between routes during their daily travels.
Then the pizza started doing the talking, with early local coverage reporting that word spread quickly about chef Vasyl Lemberskyy’s inventive combinations and personal approach to pizza making.
Lemberskyy described his pizza as neither Italian nor American in style, leaving room for a menu that could wander beyond familiar expectations without abandoning the comfort of a good pie.
Garlic sauce became a recurring attraction, appearing across combinations that bring chicken, roasted potatoes, fresh vegetables, and other toppings into territory far beyond the usual pepperoni debate.

Meanwhile, familiar tomato-based pizzas kept the menu approachable, giving groups room to experiment without requiring every person at the table to sign up for an edible adventure.
The original owners also envisioned an engaging dining room, with an open kitchen that allowed their outgoing pizza maker to interact with customers rather than disappear behind closed doors.
That welcoming spirit found an audience among local writers, including Milwaukee Record staff members who made Transfer a destination for monthly meetings over pizza.

Live music offered another reason to linger, with a 2025 Urban Milwaukee review describing local musicians performing in an intimate setting while customers enjoyed their meals.
The same reviewer praised relaxed, efficient service and recounted a server declining to offer Caprese because that day’s tomatoes did not meet the restaurant’s expectations.
And for a wonderfully Milwaukee measure of loyalty, that review described another visit when the temperature hit minus four degrees, yet every front-room table near the bar was occupied.
Food Highlights

-
Hot Rod: Marinara, parmesan, oregano, spicy sausage, bacon, fresh mozzarella, and basil give this pizza plenty of personality. Milwaukee Record praised its combination of toppings and dough, making it a tempting starting point for meat lovers. 🍕
-
Roasted Potato Chicken: Garlic sauce, cheese, chicken, and potatoes make this a hearty departure from an ordinary chicken pizza. A local reviewer praised the complementary flavors and the sauce’s ability to support everything without taking over. 🥔
-
Bruschetta Salami: Toasted Italian bread arrives with garlic sauce, Roma tomatoes, basil, salami, and shaved asiago. Urban Milwaukee’s enthusiastic review included a server’s observation that some customers visit specifically for this appetizer, so leaving room for starters seems sensible. 🍅

-
Stacy’s Special: BBQ sauce, cheese, chicken, red onion, and smoked gouda give this pizza its smoky direction. Local praise for its tender chicken and smoky zest makes it a particularly appealing option for barbecue fans. 🍗
-
The Dill: Garlic sauce, cheese, dill pickle, bacon, parmesan, and fresh dill build a specialty around tangy, savory ingredients. Pickle enthusiasts get an order that commits to the theme instead of treating pickles as an afterthought. 🥒
-
Allium: Black garlic sauce, cheese, red onions, leeks, and chives create an onion-family showcase. This is an intriguing choice for diners who want to explore the menu’s less conventional combinations without heading toward meat-heavy toppings. 🧄
-
Spinach & Artichoke Dip: Spinach and artichoke hearts mingle in parmesan-laden Alfredo sauce beneath shaved asiago, accompanied by toasted Italian bread. A local reviewer praised the warm dip alongside its crunchy bread, giving the table another reason to share. 🧀

Atmosphere
History supplies the personality, with preserved stained glass, restored woodwork, and a diner-style counter connecting the restaurant to its earlier life.
An intimate bar, artwork, and live music add layers to the experience, creating a neighborhood setting where the room itself gives diners something to enjoy between bites.

Bottom Line
Visit for inventive garlic-sauce pizzas, historic surroundings with genuine neighborhood roots, and live music that gives dinner an extra dimension.
Transfer makes a convincing case for staying beyond the last slice.
Address: 101 W Mitchell St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
📞 (414) 763-0438
🕔 Open Tue–Sun, 11 AM–9 PM | Closed Mon
