The first time locals walked into The Post, they found giant New York–style slices that felt straight out of a big-city slice shop.
The former VFW building turned cozy pizza bar gave Germantown a spot that felt familiar yet fresh, perfect for easy weeknight dinners and late-night cravings.
People kept coming back for those foldable slices, cold beer, and friendly staff who remembered faces and favorite orders.
Before long, The Post had become that comforting neighborhood pizza ritual that Louisvillians plan their week around.
How The Post won locals’ hearts
Locals first fell in love with The Post through its New York–style pizza by the slice, which makes it easy to pop in for a quick, satisfying bite.
The slices are large, foldable, and loaded with toppings, so one piece feels like a full meal without being fussy.
People appreciate that they can grab a simple cheese or pepperoni slice and know it will be hot, crisp, and consistent every time.
Germantown regulars also love the building’s roots as a former VFW post, giving the space a laid-back, lived-in feel that matches the neighborhood.
There’s a natural flow here: order at the counter, grab a drink, and settle in without any pressure or pretense.
The Post keeps its menu focused on pizza, sandwiches, and a few essentials, which helps everything taste dialed-in instead of overcomplicated.
Specialty pies bring in the more adventurous eaters, with bold flavors and fun combinations that still feel like comfort food.
That mix of classic slices and creative pies means everyone at the table can find something they’re excited about.
Portions are generous but still reasonably priced, which makes it an easy choice for families, students, and after-work groups.
Friendly service plays a big role too; staff are casual, patient, and happy to steer newcomers toward their favorite pies.
Over time, The Post has become a place where people celebrate small wins, catch up with friends, or just unwind with a slice and a beer.
In the end, they won local hearts by keeping things simple, warm, and reliably delicious, night after night.
Food Highlights
-
Pepperoni Slice: A must-try classic with a thin, foldable crust, crispy pepperoni, tangy sauce, and melty cheese. It hits all the comfort-pizza notes. Perfect for first-timers or late-night bites. 🍕
-
Cheese Slice: A go-to for purists. It features a lightly charred crust, clean tomato sauce, and smooth, balanced cheese. Simple and satisfying. A great way to judge the basics.
-
Great Colossus (Pesto Chicken Pizza): A flavorful mix of herby pesto and tender chicken. It is rich and garlicky, with pesto that soaks into the crust without feeling heavy. 🌿
-
South Pacific Pizza: A fun sweet-and-savory option with pineapple and sweet chili notes. Great for fans of Hawaiian-style pizza who want something with extra personality. 🍍
-
Chicken and Waffle Pizza (Special): A bold combo of Nashville hot chicken and sweet waffle-inspired flavors. Spicy, sweet, and memorable. This one stands out. 🔥
-
Meat-Focused Specialty Pizza: Loaded with toppings like sausage and pepperoni on a New York-style crust. Hearty and shareable. Indulgent without going overboard.
-
Hearty Subs and Sandwiches: The subs are massive and satisfying, often praised by regulars. A solid pick if you want something filling beyond pizza.
Atmosphere
The Post has a casual, neighborhood-bar feel with the bones of its old VFW life still visible, giving it a relaxed, slightly nostalgic charm.
Long tables, buzzing conversation, and the clink of glasses make it easy to settle in with friends, family, or a date without feeling rushed.
It’s the kind of place where you can show up in jeans, order at the counter, and feel like you belong by the time your slice hits the table.
On busy nights, the energy feels like a friendly community hangout, more like a local living room than a polished restaurant.
Bottom Line
Come for the giant New York–style slices, stay for the creative specialty pies and easygoing neighborhood vibe.
If you love comfort-food pizza, cold beer, and relaxed, local energy, The Post deserves a spot on your Louisville must-try list.
Address: 1045 Goss Ave, Louisville, KY 40217
📞 (502) 635-2020
🕔 Open daily, 11:30 AM–12:00 AM