Tucked inside the bustling Graceland Shopping Center, Pat and Gracie’s has quickly become a beloved staple for locals craving honest, scratch-made American fare.
Every bite tells a story, and the warm, welcoming vibe makes you feel like part of the family from the moment you walk in.
This isn’t just another tavern—it’s a tribute to Columbus history, served up with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that keep guests coming back week after week.
From the first bite of their legendary tater tots to the last sip of a craft cocktail, Pat and Gracie’s delivers an experience that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly new.
How Pat and Gracie’s won Graceland hearts
When owners Matt Rootes, Craig Chapman, and Tony Wildman opened the Graceland Blvd location, they leaned into something deeper than burgers—they embraced Columbus history with a menu that felt both nostalgic and new.
The restaurant honors Patrick “Pat” Murnan and Grace “Gracie” Backenstow, a legendary early-1900s power couple who once ruled the city’s underground scene with gambling halls and horse farms.
That backstory, paired with a no-freezer, all-fresh kitchen philosophy, turned curious diners into loyal regulars almost overnight.
Word spread fast—roughly 900 guests a week showed up for smash burgers, craft cocktails, and that warm, neighborhood-tavern feel.
Locals loved the honest food, friendly vibes, and a menu that felt like home, making it the go-to spot for everything from casual lunches to weekend hangouts.
“We cannot thank the Clintonville Community enough for how they have supported us,” said Rootes, and that gratitude shows in every detail, from the handmade mozzarella sticks to the locally tapped beers.
The team focused on scratch-made tavern food that prioritized quality over quantity, earning a reputation for dishes that actually taste like they came from a home kitchen.
Even the tater tots became legendary, with the owners noting they’re the biggest seller by far and a must-try for first-time visitors.
Customers rave about the family-type, cozy feeling that makes every visit feel like catching up with old friends.
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual, lively, and unpretentious, think neighborhood tavern meets modern American eatery.
Guests appreciate the welcoming staff, cozy booths, and a bar that actually knows its cocktails, creating a space where everyone feels comfortable.
It’s the kind of place where you can catch a game, grab a craft beer, or settle in for a long lunch with friends, and that’s exactly why locals keep coming back.
Food Highlights
-
Chimi Burger: Two smashed patties with Monterey Jack, avocado, caramelized onions, and house chimichurri; a fan-favorite for its bold, fresh twist that keeps customers ordering it again and again. 🍔🔥
-
Salmon BLT: A lighter star, pairing flaky salmon with crisp bacon and lettuce for a brunch-worthy classic that proves healthy can still be indulgent. 🐟🥗
-
Smokehouse BBQ Burger: Smoky, saucy, and stacked with all the fixings for BBQ lovers who want their burger to taste like a backyard cookout. 🍖🍯
-
Fresh-Cut Mozzarella Sticks: Made from real mozzarella blocks, never frozen; the owners’ top appetizer pick that arrives crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. 🧀✨
-
Pimento Cheese Melt: House-made pimento cheese, bacon, and pickles on sourdough; comfort food at its finest with a tangy kick that pairs perfectly with a cold beer. 🥪😋
-
Fried Chicken Cobb Salad: A hearty salad with crispy chicken, perfect for those wanting greens with crunch and a dressing that ties everything together beautifully. 🥗🍗
Atmosphere
The vibe is casual, lively, and unpretentious—think neighborhood tavern meets modern American eatery with kitschy chandeliers and painted horses that nod to the restaurant’s historical namesakes.
Guests rave about the welcoming staff, cozy booths, and a bar that actually knows its cocktails, creating a space where everyone feels comfortable and never rushed.
Bottom Line
Scratch-made, freezer-free menu and rich local history make this a must-visit for anyone craving authentic American fare.
Friendly, community-focused service and solid burgers create the perfect spot for casual hangouts, date nights, or catching a game with friends.
Address: 138 Graceland Blvd, Columbus, OH 43214
📞 (614) 987-5147
🕔 Open Mon- Fri 11am-8:30pm | Sat 10:30am – 9:30PM | Sun 10:30am – 8:30pm