In the heart of Columbus’s German Village, The Thurman Cafe has flipped burgers since 1942.
Family-owned from the start, this spot draws crowds with massive, loaded patties that locals can’t resist.
Opened by Nick Suclescy and passed down through generations, it keeps traditions alive amid long lines.
Fame hit big with TV spots like Man v. Food, yet the vibe stays dive-bar cozy.
How The Thurman Cafe won locals’ hearts
Picture a tiny tavern in 1942 where Nick Suclescy fires up the first sizzling burgers on a flat-top griddle.
Word spreads fast in German Village— these aren’t ordinary patties; they’re towering beasts stuffed with toppings that challenge jaws and appetites alike.
By staying true to roots, the family never chased trends, just perfected those hefty hamburgers through decades of loyal fans.
Then boom—Travel Channel’s Man v. Food rolls in, pitting host Adam Richman against the monstrous Thurmanator, catapulting this Columbus gem to national buzz.
Suddenly, lines snake out the door from out-of-towners chasing the legend, but locals grin because they’ve known the magic forever.
Dollar bills plaster walls from pilgrims nationwide, each one a testament to burgers that conquer hunger and spark stories.
Generational recipes like the famous Coney Island keep elders coming back, while epic stacks hook the young.
No fancy renovations, just that gritty charm and consistent sizzle winning hearts one bite at a time.
What began as neighborhood fuel evolved into a bucket-list rite, proving simple, bold flavors beat hype every day.
Food Highlights
-
The Thurman Burger: Overloaded with ham, sautéed onions & mushrooms, mozzarella & American cheese, a must-try for its massive, flavor-packed layers that locals rave about.
-
The Thurmanator: Two 12-oz patties with bacon, cheddar, mushrooms, ham, and cheeses—famous from TV as the ultimate challenge burger drawing epic reviews.
-
The Jason Burger: Topped with egg, bacon, salami, mozzarella over coleslaw and fries, popular for its wild, indulgent toppings that satisfy big appetites.
-
Bacon Burger: Burger with bacon and mozzarella fully dressed, a go-to favorite for smoky, cheesy perfection in every bite.
-
Mushroom Burger: Heaped with mushrooms and mozzarella, loved for earthy flavors and gooey cheese that keeps fans returning.
-
The Western Burger: Loaded with bacon, cheddar, BBQ sauce, a crowd-pleaser for its tangy, hearty Western twist.
Atmosphere
Dim lights glow amid neon beer signs and walls papered in customer dollar bills from across the country.
Shabby, eclectic dive-bar feel mixes with buzzing energy from locals and tourists alike. Cozy booths and a packed bar create that unpretentious hangout vibe.
Quirky memorabilia adds fun chaos to the nostalgic spot.
Bottom Line
Visit for legendary oversized burgers like the Thurmanator, family legacy since 1942, TV fame vibes, dollar-bill walls, and German Village charm all in one unforgettable feast.
Address: 183 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206
📞 (614) 443-1570
🕔 Sun-Thu 11AM–11PM, Fri-Sat 11AM–12AM