In a city packed with pizza chains and corporate restaurants, one small family-owned spot has managed to capture the hearts—and taste buds—of Mesa residents through sheer passion and exceptional pizza.
Twisted Pies Pizzeria has built a loyal following by staying true to their roots while creating unique twists that keep customers coming back for more. 🍕
Their journey from a quirky nickname to becoming a Mesa favorite proves that authentic food and genuine care can triumph over flashy marketing any day.
How they won Mesas’ hearts
Twisted Pies Pizzeria didn’t achieve local fame overnight—it earned every bite of recognition through dedication and innovation.
The restaurant has been serving Mesa since 2015, but truly hit its stride when new owners took over in November 2023, bringing fresh energy while maintaining the beloved traditions that customers cherished.
Their success stems from a simple philosophy: use the freshest ingredients, create memorable experiences, and treat every customer like family.
What truly sets them apart is their commitment to quality—they cut, slice, dice, and shred fresh ingredients daily rather than relying on pre-processed toppings.
The wood-fired oven creates that perfect crispy crust that customers rave about, while their house-made marinara sauce provides the ideal foundation for their creations.
But perhaps most importantly, they’ve built genuine relationships with their community, becoming the type of neighborhood spot where regulars feel like they’re visiting old friends rather than just ordering food.
Food Highlights
- Perfect Pepperoni Pizza: Their signature creation features pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, basil, and garlic that creates what customers consistently call “the best pepperoni pizza” they’ve ever had. The combination of wood-fired cooking and fresh ingredients elevates this classic beyond typical pizza joint fare.
- Shirley Pie Pizza: A meat lover’s dream loaded with ham, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, pepperoncinis, red onion, and black olives that has earned devoted fans who drive over five miles specifically for this pizza. The generous toppings and perfect seasoning balance make this their most requested specialty pie.
- Sweet N’ Spicy Pizza: This innovative creation combines pepperoni, spicy sausage, and jalapeños with fresh mozzarella, then tops it with a swirl of honey garlic hot sauce for a flavor profile that perfectly balances heat with sweetness.
- Godfather Pizza: A protein-packed masterpiece featuring bacon, ham, pepperoni, and sweet sausage that lives up to its commanding name with abundant toppings and bold Italian flavors that satisfy even the heartiest appetites.
- Twisted Muffins: Their unique take on pizza rolls, these oversized “muffins” are actually personal pizzas rolled up and baked in monster muffin pans, creating a novel dining experience that customers describe as both delicious and Instagram-worthy.
- Margherita Pizza: Made with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and basil, this classic showcases their commitment to traditional Italian flavors while highlighting the superior taste their wood-fired oven imparts to every pie.
Atmosphere
Step inside Twisted Pies Pizzeria and you’ll immediately feel the warmth and laughter that defines this cozy neighborhood gem.
The intimate space invites families and friends to gather around tables where conversations flow as freely as the perfectly melted cheese on their pizzas. 💫
Unlike sterile chain restaurants, this spot buzzes with genuine energy—you can watch the magic happen as pizzas emerge from their wood-fired oven, creating an interactive dining experience that keeps kids entertained and adults fascinated.
The family-owned atmosphere permeates every corner, from the friendly staff to the owners who genuinely care about creating memorable experiences rather than just processing transactions.
ALSO IN MESA: How This Small Burger Spot Won Locals Hearts in Mesa, AZ
Bottom Line
Twisted Pies Pizzeria represents truly everything great about local dining—authentic flavors, genuine hospitality, and a commitment to quality that transforms a simple meal into a community experience.
For anyone seeking proof that independent restaurants can still thrive through passion and excellence, Twisted Pies serves up that evidence one perfectly crafted slice at a time.
Address: 3929 E Main St #16, Mesa, AZ 85205
📞 (480) 699-8022
🕔 Mon-Sat: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Sun: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM