Baby Doll Pizza delivers New York-style pies with Portland flair at its original spot on SE Stark Street.
Since opening in 2011, this joint has hooked locals with bold flavors and massive slices that satisfy cravings fast.
Fans rave about the smoky marinara and crispy crusts, turning quick bites into neighborhood rituals.
Dive into why this pizzeria rules Portland’s pizza scene!
How Baby Doll Pizza won locals’ hearts
Imagine cruising down SE Stark Street, your stomach growling for something real.
That’s when Baby Doll Pizza burst onto the scene in 2011, flipping the script on Portland’s pizza game with authentic New York-style pies that hit different.
Locals didn’t just try it – they fell hard. Word spread like wildfire through the Hawthorne district as folks discovered huge, foldable slices sold by the piece, perfect for on-the-go munching or late-night hangs.
Willamette Week’s Readers’ Poll crowned them #1 in 2025 – their fourth straight year dominating the charts, winner 2025, 2nd in 2024 and 2023, 3rd in 2022.
Reviewers obsess over the white pie’s creamy ricotta magic and pepperoni slices that deliver one-bite-through crunch without flop.
Fans declare they’ll stop every drive down Stark, hooked on that smoky marinara kick.
Portland Eater calls it the quintessential neighborhood joint amid fierce competition, while OneBite pizza pros praise generous toppings and no-sweet sauce.
Consistency sealed the deal: in-house dough, local veggies, house-made meats like brisket meatballs.
No gimmicks, just pizza perfection that keeps ’em coming back.
This spot didn’t chase trends; it built a cult following through killer quality and that unpretentious vibe.
Now, it’s not just pizza, it’s Portland’s pizza heartbeat.
Food Highlights
-
#7 White Pie: Olive oil base topped with mozzarella, house-made ricotta, parm, caramelized onion, garlic on sesame crust- no red sauce. Creamy, garlicky dream that white pie fans crave for its rich, sauce-free perfection. 🧀
-
Pepperoni Pie: House tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, loaded premium pepperoni cups. Crispy one-bite-through edges and generous meat make it a top pick for classic lovers. 🔥
-
#1 Margherita: Garlic, fresh basil, house mozzarella on tomato base. Pure, fresh simplicity shines with quality ingredients – must-try for NY-style purists. 🌿
-
#6 Veggie Pie: Artichoke hearts, red pepper, red onion, kalamata olives, feta, garlic. Tangy, briny veggie blast with feta zing – perfect shareable for flavor explorers. 🥬
-
#4 Spicy Pie: Hot soppressata, pepper jack, pepperoncini, mozzarella. Spicy heat balanced by melty cheese – spice fiends call it essential. 🌶️
Atmosphere
Baby Doll Pizza buzzes with offbeat, casual charm on SE Stark.
Dark lighting, quirky decor, and a laid-back neighborhood feel invite quick slices or hour-long hangs.
Big communal tables foster easy chats among locals, grabbing beers and pies.
It’s the spot where Portland attitude meets pizza passion – unfussy yet unforgettable.
No pretension, just good vibes and killer slices flowing from the open kitchen.
Bottom Line
Visit for award-winning slices, huge portions, by-the-slice ease, bold specials, and that addictive NY-Portland mashup.
You won’t leave hungry!
Address: 2835 SE Stark St, Portland, OR 97214
📞 (503) 459-4450
🕔 Mon 4 pm – 11 pm, Thu-Thu, Sun 11 am – 11 pm, Fri-Sat 11 am – 12 am