George Street has long served as the industrial spine of the city, but the salty, savory aroma drifting from Rockfish Public House transports diners straight to the Annapolis docks.
This isn’t just a neighborhood grill; it is the culmination of a journey that began when Jeremiah Anderson first started washing dishes at fifteen years old.
By channeling a technical “shore-to-table” philosophy and an obsession with Eastern Shore quality, Jeremiah successfully built an iconic PHENOMENON inside a historic 19th-century shoe warehouse. 🦐⛴️
The Grit Behind the George Street Legend
The primary driver of the local obsession is the restaurant’s unwavering commitment to Chesapeake authenticity, a standard set by founder Jeremiah Anderson and General Manager Robert Faucette.
Jeremiah’s journey is the ultimate story of local grit; having started his career washing dishes at the age of 15, he spent over a decade working his way through the ranks to master the technical nuances of the kitchen before launching this flagship concept.
His vision was to honor the building’s industrial past—once home to Peterman’s Wholesale Shoes—maintaining an independent, gritty-yet-refined energy where exposed brick walls and high ceilings provide a sophisticated backdrop for his world-class raw bar selections. 🏠📖
The soul of the operation lies in the technical fusion of the “Crab Smash,” a massive burger topped with a 5-ounce colossal crab cake that has become a citywide benchmark for indulgence.
Under Jeremiah’s leadership, the kitchen utilizes proprietary shore sauces and technical frying methods that maintain the crab’s integrity, creating a signature dish that corporate franchises simply cannot replicate.
This independent, community-first spirit has redefined the downtown experience for York residents, primarily through a raw bar program featuring the “Shuckin’ Tower,” a technical showcase of wild-caught oysters that keeps the George Street corridor vibrant long into the evening. 🌟🤝
What truly anchors the experience is the connection to Maryland tradition, most notably seen in the rare inclusion of the Smith Island Cake on the dessert menu.
This technical multi-layered masterpiece—the official state cake of Maryland—serves as a final nod to the restaurant’s namesake, the Striped Bass.
This focus on heritage and technical consistency has earned the restaurant a sterling reputation among Pennsylvania tastemakers. 🏆✨
The Lineup & Must-Try Bites
-
Crab Smash Burger is the undisputed star; featuring a proprietary beef blend topped with a colossal 5-ounce Maryland crab cake.
-
Shuckin’ Tower represents the heart of the raw bar, offering a technical tiered display of oysters, clams, and chilled lobster.
-
Chesapeake Rockfish Entree provide a massive, local favorite for those seeking the namesake fish, prepared with a technical lemon-butter sear.
-
Colossal Crab Cocktail is a masterclass in simplicity, featuring premium lump crab meat and a house-made technical cocktail sauce.
-
Maryland Crab Soup is a flavor-driven mystery favorite, prepared with a traditional tomato base and a specific technical spice blend.
-
Shore Style Mussels showcase the kitchen’s technical respect for bivalves, steamed in a garlic-white wine broth with fresh herbs.
-
Fried Oyster Po’ Boy is the soul of the lunch menu, featuring a technical cornmeal crust and zesty remoulade.
-
Seared Scallops With Risotto offer a delicate and traditional take on seafood, prepared with technical precision for a perfect golden crust.
-
Smith Island Cake is prepared with thin, technical layers of yellow cake and rich chocolate fudge, honoring its Maryland roots.
-
Rockfish Signature Mule is a fan favorite, providing a crisp and refreshing finish that highlights the bar’s commitment to craft infusions.
Atmosphere
The energy approaching the restaurant is defined by the historic brick facade of the George Street corridor, where the 19th-century architecture meets a modern, maritime-inspired interior.
From the sidewalk, the vibrant hum of the raw bar and the industrial-chic lighting visible through the massive windows create a sense of arrival at the city’s most reliable social crossroads.
It remains the essential destination for a York weekend dinner or a midday escape that feels entirely original to the South Central Pennsylvania seafood scene. 🦀⚓
The Bottom Line
The kitchen at Rockfish Public House functions as a high-octane, polished love letter to Chesapeake culture and local resilience.
You should visit because the shore-to-table technicality provides a level of flavor depth that elevates Maryland traditions into a genuine York landmark.
Every guest leaves with a clearer understanding of why the most vibrant spot on George Street is the one born from Jeremiah’s fifteen-year-old dream. 🥇
📍 110 N George St, York, PA 17401
📞 (717) 893-5789
🕔 Tue-Thu: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM |Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM |Sun-Mon: Closed