For over 26 years, Gilbert’s on Main has been Bellevue’s only authentic deli sandwich experience, serving breakfast and lunch to generations of loyal customers.
Owner Steve Gilbert is known for meeting, greeting, and kibitzing with patrons, creating an atmosphere where families, business meetings, couples, and singles blend into the unique “Gilbert’s Culture.”
Located in Old Town Bellevue, this warm and convivial gathering spot features over 25 show-stopping sandwiches, including the legendary #9 Reuben.
The breakfast and lunch menus deliver New York-style deli authenticity west of the Hudson, with fresh bagels, oversized portions, and weekend music creating the perfect ambiance. 🥯
How Gilbert’s on Main Won Bellevue’s Hearts
Gilbert’s captured Bellevue’s devotion by delivering genuinely authentic New York-style deli experience that families have enjoyed for 14 years and counting.
Their legendary #9 Reuben towers high with corned beef, reminiscent of the most famous delis of New York and earning consistent praise as worth every penny.
The matzo ball soup earns recognition as the best west of NYC, featuring classic preparation with just the right amount of schmaltz.
Customers who’ve lived in New York, Europe, and California report that Gilbert’s maintains international flair with homemade fresh food that rivals authentic delis anywhere.
The gargantuan portions mean you can split dishes or plan for leftovers, with omelettes arriving with heaps of excellent potatoes and whole bagels with cream cheese and jam.
Beautiful photo books to browse, great outdoor seating, and Steve’s personal touch create a place to gather, meet friends, or even write the Great American Novel on your laptop.
Food Highlights
- Gilbert’s Deluxe Lox & Bagel Plate: This show-stopping breakfast features tender lox over an ample bagel with all the traditional accompaniments for an authentic New York experience.
- #9 Reuben Sandwich: The legendary high-stacked masterpiece piled with tender corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on grilled rye that’s reminiscent of New York’s most famous delis. 🥪
-
Matzo Ball Soup: Called the best west of NYC, this classic Jewish comfort food features the largest matzo ball customers have ever seen, with just the right amount of schmaltz.
-
French Toast: One of the most popular breakfast items, this enormous portion is so huge that customers report they could have split one order instead of each ordering their own. 🥞
- French Onion Soup: This rich, savory soup, topped with melted cheese, delivers classic bistro flavors.
- Tomato Florentine Soup: This vegetable-forward option provides a lighter soup choice alongside the heartier matzo ball.
- Pastrami Sandwich: This deli classic features hand-carved pastrami piled high on fresh bread.
-
Hot Beef Sandwich with Port Wine Au Jus: This indulgent specialty features tender beef with rich port wine au jus for those seeking something beyond traditional deli fare
-
One Egg Omelets: These hearty breakfast options arrive with heaps of excellent potatoes and a whole bagel with cream cheese and jam included.
-
Apple Gorgonzola Salad: This oversized fresh salad gets even better when you add garlic chicken, with portions so large you might want to order a half.
-
Pancakes: Featured in breakfast combos, these enormous flapjacks arrive so large that one pancake could satisfy most appetites.
- Fresh Bagels with Cream Cheese: These authentic New York-style bagels done perfectly—not overcooked or under-toasted—form the foundation of Gilbert’s breakfast menu
Atmosphere
The down-scale interior with counter service creates authentic deli vibes that feel transported from New York rather than polished Bellevue.
Beautiful photo books scattered throughout invite browsing while you wait for your order, creating a relaxed environment perfect for lingering.
The great outdoor seating on Main Street provides people-watching opportunities in Old Town Bellevue’s charming neighborhood.
Bottom Line
Visit for an authentic New York-style deli experience with 26 years of tradition, legendary #9 Reuben rivaling NYC’s best, matzo ball soup called best west of NYC, gargantuan portions worth the price, and Steve Gilbert’s personal hospitality.
Address:
10024 Main Street, Bellevue, WA 98004
đź“ž (425) 455-5650
🕔 Open Daily, 8:00 AM–3:00 PM