Best All-Natural Burgers in Midtown Manhattan – New York, NY

All-Natural Patties, Fast Service, and Big Flavor in the Heart of Midtown Manhattan

By Alvin Estañol
Best BurgersBlogDestinationsFoodInstagrammableNew YorkNew York City
Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Name
Black Iron Burger
Address
245 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018
Hours
Open daily 11 AM–11 PM (check site for updates)

Tucked amid Midtown’s hustle at 245 W 38th St, Black Iron Burger delivers bold, all-natural burgers that locals can’t resist.

This spot opened its doors in 2014, fast becoming a theater district favorite for hearty, hormone-free patties grilled to smoky perfection.

Crowds flock here for the guilt-free indulgence, antibiotic-free beef paired with fresh toppings that satisfy without overwhelming.

Friendly service shines even at peak times, turning first-timers into regulars amid Times Square frenzy.

Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Nick

How Black Iron Burger won locals’ hearts

Picture a compact burger haven drawing theater-goers away from flashy chains.

Black Iron Burger captured hearts with its cheeky “Nobody Beats Our Meat” slogan that promises top-tier quality.

Locals buzzed about the customizable, juicy patties hitting harder than nearby tourist traps.

Word traveled through NYC food circles, praising the perfect char and vibrant flavors from fresh ingredients.

Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Kaiylah

Staff hustle plates out in minutes, keeping energy high without chaos.

By blending hearty portions with lighter options, it earned loyalty as the go-to for post-show fuel.

This under-the-radar joint transformed Midtown foot traffic into devoted fans, one sizzling bite at a time.

Food Highlights

Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Simon

  • Masterpiece Burger: Loaded with premium toppings for explosive flavor; a must-try for its bold taste that keeps diners coming back.

  • Signature BIB Burger: Classic Angus beef grilled just right; popular for its reliable perfection every visit.

  • Patty Melt: Savory patty meets gooey cheese bliss; loved as a comforting twist on tradition.

  • Smash Burger: Crispy-edged daily special delight; fans crave its fresh, smash-house texture.

  • Iberico Burger: Exotic pork patty with thoughtful pairings; stands as an adventurous standout hit.

  • BIB Cheeseburger: Simple yet supreme cheese-meets-beef harmony; a crowd favorite for purity.

Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Karen

Atmosphere

Enter to warm sports bar vibes with glowing TVs tuned to big games.

Fairy lights and lively music set a cozy, upbeat tone.

It’s snug during rushes, boosting that communal energy.

Ideal for quick bites or group hangs.

Photos for Black Iron Burger in New York, NY
Dave

Bottom Line

Go for juicy custom burgers, zippy service, vibrant atmosphere, fresh meats, and Midtown convenience—pure bliss!

Address: 245 W 38th St, New York, NY 10018

📞 (212) 290-7740

🕔 Open daily 11 AM–11 PM (check site for updates)