If you’re wandering around the East Village and suddenly find yourself craving pizza, Nuovo York Pizza might just be the place that stops you in your tracks, not with hype, but because of what locals and visitors actually say about it. This over-the-counter slice spot has become a reliable choice for people who want that classic New York pie: thin crust, big slices, and flavors that feel familiar and satisfying, whether it’s lunch, dinner, or 2 AM pizza time. Reviews consistently praise the pizza’s freshness, crust quality, and service, and the place earns solid marks for big slices and fair prices in a neighborhood packed with options.
How It Started and What It Is
Nuovo York Pizza doesn’t come with a long, dramatic origin story; there’s no famous chef angle or viral founder moment, but sometimes that’s the point. What you do find is an East Village pizza joint that started as a straightforward idea: make good pizza, serve it fast, and keep people happy so they come back. Over the years, it’s built a reputation for authentic New York-style slices, with some people calling its thin, crunchy crust and generous cheese “the gold standard of NYC pizza” in recent reviews.
Located near Astor Place and easy to reach from subways and throughout downtown Manhattan, it’s become a common recommendation for anyone who wants a quick, solid slice without the wait, especially late at night. Many reviewers appreciate that it’s open very late compared with a lot of other pizza places, making it a go-to after shows, work, or a night out.
What People Like Most
A big part of Nuovo York Pizza’s appeal is its simplicity done well. Instead of a sprawling, complicated menu with dozens of pies, it focuses on nods to classic New York pizza styles and a few creative slants you don’t always see by the slice. Customer reviews highlight the generous portion sizes and the freshness of every slice, and many people mention the staff’s friendly, welcoming service, the kind that makes regulars feel comfortable, and visitors feel like they’ve stumbled onto a neighborhood gem.
Food Highlights
- Classic Cheese Slice: Thin, foldable, and balanced.
- Pepperoni Slice: A timeless favorite.
- Vodka Sauce Slice: Creamy with a NYC feel.
- Margherita Slice: Fresh and simple.
- Pesto Pepperoni Slice: Bright and flavorful.
- Square Pie Options: Thicker, chewier slices.
Beyond these, you’ll find a range of by-the-slice and whole-pie options, including gluten-free pies, heart-shaped pizzas, calzones, and rolls, so there’s usually something for everyone in a group.
What Customers Actually Say
Walk into Nuovo York Pizza, and you’ll hear descriptors in reviews like “crispy,” “fresh,” “super fast pie making,” and “reasonable prices for Manhattan.” People frequently comment on how the crust hits that nice balance of thin and crunchy without feeling too flat, and that the sauce and toppings feel well-matched and not overly heavy.
Jiayi L.
Many customers mention that the space is chill and casual, the kind of place where you can grab a slice on your way home or hang out with friends without fuss. Compared to some pizza places where lines spill out the door, Nuovo York feels accessible and straightforward, which is part of its charm.
A few reviewers have discussed the high rating on review platforms and raised eyebrows about the number of 5-star reviews, but most still concede that the pizza itself is solid and worth trying if you’re in the area.
Atmosphere
The vibe at Nuovo York Pizza is casual, friendly, and low-pressure. You’ll see folks grabbing slices between errands, college students stopping by for a quick bite, and visitors sampling pizza as part of their New York experience.
Seating is relaxed and unhurried, not fancy, just comfortable, and the overall feel is easygoing, like any good neighborhood pizza spot should be. Plenty of people mention that the slice shop feels welcoming without trying too hard, and that the staff seem genuinely nice and attentive.
Allison C.
Bottom Line
Here’s why Nuovo York Pizza is worth a stop if you’re in the East Village:
- Classic NYC-style slices with crispy, thin crust.
- Creative options like vodka and pesto pepperoni slices.
- Open very late, perfect for early morning or late-night cravings.
- Friendly service and relaxed, informal atmosphere.
- Good value for the quality and portion size.
Nuovo York Pizza
📍 105 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003
📞 (646) 476-2428
🕔 Open daily 9 AM – 4:30 AM (next day)
(nuovoyorkpizza.com)