Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria on Underwood Avenue in Omaha is the kind of place that makes pizza people sit up straighter.
The menu is built around a coal-fire oven, and the Dundee location is listed at 5021 Underwood Ave with the number 402-590-2625.
That’s the simple part.
The interesting part is how many people seem to treat it like a full-on destination, not just a pizza stop. 🍕🔥
How Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria in Omaha won locals’ hearts
Pitch’s appeal starts with the oven, but it doesn’t end there.
Public listings describe it as a coal-fire pizzeria, and customer reviews repeatedly frame it as a place that delivers more than a basic pie night.
One longtime reviewer called it an “Omaha gem,” praising the food, the service, and a bar program that helps the restaurant feel like a destination rather than a quick stop.
That loyalty seems to come from a mix of consistency and variety.
Reviews mention well-seasoned pastas, fresh salads, and appetizers that hold their own next to the pizzas, which matters because a lot of pizza spots can only really survive on the strength of the crust.
Pitch appears to have built its reputation by making the whole meal feel worth the trip, especially when the room is busy and a little loud in the best possible way. ✨
Food Highlights at Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria in Omaha
-
Margherita Pizza: Reviewers describe it as a reliable favorite, and the menu lists it with San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
-
Mushroom Pizza / Shrooms: The menu calls it Shrooms, with thyme cream, mozzarella, sautéed mushroom, oven-roasted tomato, truffle oil, Parmesan, and fresh parsley.
- Chorizo Pizza: The menu doesn’t list a chorizo pizza by that exact name, but it does offer pies like Mia and Dos or Tres Peps that lean savory and bold.
-
Calamari: The popular-dishes list includes calamari, which suggests it’s a common starter choice.
-
Brussels Sprouts: The menu includes Spicy Pistachio Brussels Sprouts and Roasted Pancetta Brussels Sprouts, so this is clearly a real highlight, not an afterthought.
-
Pasta and Salads: Public listings and reviews point to a broader menu beyond pizza, with salads and other plates helping Pitch feel like a full restaurant.
Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria’s atmosphere
Pitch’s atmosphere sounds busy, lively, and energetic during peak hours, with a loud room and packed weekends that give it real momentum.
Even so, reviewers say the service is attentive and welcoming, so the energy feels more like a vibrant scene than chaos.
Bottom Line
Go for the coal-fire pizza, stay for the broader menu, and plan for a lively room.
The restaurant has enough variety to satisfy non-pizza eaters, enough energy to feel like a scene, and enough positive word of mouth to justify the trip across town. 🍽️
Address: 5021 Underwood Ave Omaha, NE 68132
📞 402-590-2625
🕔 Hours: Sun- Thu 11:00AM – 9:00PM | Wed – Thu 11:00AM -9:00PM | Fri 11:00AM -11:00PM | Sat 10:00AM – 11:00PM