We love highlighting hard working burger shops here at Go To Destinations, and we all know that there are countless burger spots across New York you can choose from.
But finding the perfect burger in the Big Apple is like searching for a diamond in a haystack made of beef patties – thankfully, Ale ‘n’ Angus Pub, Marble + Rye, and 4 Charles Prime Rib shine brighter than a freshly polished brioche bun!
Ale ‘n’ Angus Pub
When a restaurant wins “Best Burger in New York State” seven times, burger enthusiasts need to pay attention.
Located in downtown Syracuse, this family-owned pub has created quite a buzz with its mouthwatering burgers and welcoming atmosphere.
The pub’s dedication to quality and creativity has made it a must-visit destination for food lovers across the Empire State.
Food Highlights:
- Number 7: 1/2 pound Angus burger topped with pecan smoked shoulder bacon, special burger sauce, American and pepper jack cheese on an inverted buttery croissant roll
- Power Play Burger: A signature creation that helped earn multiple state awards
- Hot & Smokey Candied Bacon Burger: Features candied bacon, pepper jack cheese, onion straws, honey, and chipotle mayo
- Billy The Kid Burger: Topped with bacon, onion jam, goat cheese, and chipotle aioli sauce
- Birria Burger: A unique creation featuring consommé and Indian-inspired spices
Atmosphere:
The cozy pub offers a warm, friendly environment with attentive service.
The space combines casual dining with a classic pub feel, making it perfect for both lunch crowds and casual dinners.
The owner’s hands-on approach adds a personal touch to the dining experience.
Why It’s One of the Best in New York:
The combination of award-winning burgers, friendly service, and consistent quality makes this pub a standout destination for burger lovers.
The innovative menu keeps regulars coming back while attracting new visitors seeking the best cheeseburgers in New York.
Address: 238 Harrison St, Syracuse, NY 13202
Marble + Rye
Buffalo’s food scene has exploded in recent years, and Marble + Rye has emerged as one of the city’s most exciting destinations for burger enthusiasts.
This trendy bar and lounge in downtown Buffalo crafts some of the best burgers in New York with an unwavering commitment to quality ingredients.
The restaurant works closely with local farms to ensure peak freshness and seasonality in every dish.
Food Highlights
- Signature Double Cheeseburger: Two grass-fed smash patties topped with American cheese, red onion, mayo, and mustard on a brioche bun, served with crispy potatoes, pickles, chimichurri, and crème fraîche
- Pickled Onion Rings: A fan favorite appetizer that perfectly complements any burger order
- Seasonal Salads: Fresh, locally-sourced greens with house dressing and brioche breadcrumbs
- Detroit-Style Pizza: A newer addition to the menu featuring various toppings on perfectly charred crust
Atmosphere
The space exudes an eclectic and fun vibe with a modern, casual elegance.
The bar showcases an impressive selection of creative cocktails and whiskeys.
Why It’s One of the Best in New York:
Marble + Rye delivers one of the best cheeseburgers in New York through its masterful combination of premium grass-fed beef, scratch-made preparation, and thoughtful ingredient sourcing.
The restaurant’s dedication to seasonal ingredients and craft cocktails creates an exceptional dining experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back.
Address: 112 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY 14203
4 Charles Prime Rib
Food lovers seeking the best burgers in New York need to make their way to 4 Charles Prime Rib in the West Village.
This intimate spot has earned its reputation as a destination for some of the best cheeseburgers in New York.
The restaurant combines old-school steakhouse vibes with modern flair, creating an experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Food Highlights
- 10oz Double Wagyu Cheeseburger: Two 5oz wagyu patties with American cheese, pickles, onion, and marie rose sauce – add farm egg or thick-cut bacon for extra indulgence
- Prime Rib French Dip: Tender prime rib with swiss cheese and natural jus
- Truffle Mac & Cheese: Black truffle and white cheddar create a luxurious side dish
- Thick Cut Bacon: Maple and black pepper glazed
- Lemon Meringue Pie: A towering dessert that’s become a customer favorite
Atmosphere
The dimly lit dining room features plush leather booths and white-glove service.
The intimate space only accommodates a handful of tables, creating an exclusive dining experience.
The restaurant’s basement location adds to its speakeasy-like charm.
Why It’s One of the Best in New York
The wagyu burger presentation includes a theatrical tableside egg-breaking ritual.
The quality of ingredients and attention to detail make every dish memorable.
Getting a reservation might be as tough as scoring concert tickets, but the experience is worth the wait.
Address: 4 Charles St, New York, NY 10014