Bloomington’s pizza scene has no shortage of options, but two spots stand out above the rest. Are these the ultimate go-to pizzerias in town? From their mouthwatering slices to their devoted fanbases, these restaurants might just be the best of the best. Let’s dive in and see if they live up to the hype!
Aver’s Pizza
Pizza lovers in Bloomington, Indiana have discovered a true gem in Aver’s Pizza, South. This award-winning pizzeria serves up creative and delicious pies daily from 11 am to 2 am. With its innovative combinations and fresh, house-made ingredients, Aver’s has built a loyal following among locals and visitors alike since opening over 20 years ago.
Food Highlights
- Cream & Crimson: An award-winning creation featuring alfredo sauce, oven-roasted red potatoes, fresh garlic, dill, bacon, cheddar, and gorgonzola cheese
- Cuban Black Bean: A unique vegetarian option with cilantro pesto sauce, onions, fresh tomatoes, and seasoned black beans
- The Whole Enchilada: Features green chili sauce, chicken, onions, cheddar, green onions, and red enchilada sauce
- Chicken Bacon Ranch: A bronze medal winner topped with ranch dressing, chicken, bacon, red onion, and tomatoes
Atmosphere
The restaurant maintains a casual and welcoming environment with friendly staff eager to provide excellent service. Their fast delivery and convenient location make it perfect for both dine-in and takeout customers.
Bottom Line
Aver’s Pizza South delivers an exceptional pizza experience with their creative combinations and high-quality ingredients. Their award-winning specialty pies and late-night hours make it a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts.
Address: 317 E. Winslow Rd., Bloomington, IN 47401
Goodfellas Pizzeria
Pizza lovers searching for an authentic New York slice in the heart of Indiana need to make their way to Goodfellas Pizzeria. This fast-casual pizzeria on Kirkwood Avenue brings a taste of the Big Apple to Bloomington with its massive slices and late-night hours.
The restaurant has earned a solid reputation among Indiana University students and locals alike for serving up some of the most satisfying pizza in town.
Food Highlights
- New York Style Pizza: Huge slices with good crisp, minimal flop, and a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio
- Tommy Two Times: A popular specialty pizza with rave reviews from regulars
- Breadsticks: Sizeable portions perfect for sharing, with customers raving about their amazing taste
- Chocolate Chip Cookie: A sizable dessert worth saving room for
Atmosphere
The restaurant offers a casual, energetic vibe perfect for both lunch crowds and late-night dining. Located right on the main strip, it’s a popular spot that can get busy during peak hours, especially given its prime location on Kirkwood Avenue.
Bottom Line
With its authentic New York-style slices, generous portions, and convenient location, Goodfellas delivers a slice of NYC right in Bloomington. It’s particularly perfect for those late-night cravings or when you’re craving a genuine New York pizza experience.
Address: 427 E Kirkwood Ave, Bloomington, IN 47408