Madison might be known for cheese, but when it comes to burgers, this town flips the script in all the best ways. From classic, no-frills patties to bold, over-the-top creations, these burger spots are more than just a meal—they’re a Madison rite of passage.
Let’s get started.
Settle Down Tavern
In the heart of Madison, WI, Settle Down Tavern invites burger enthusiasts to indulge in a delightful dining experience. This vibrant eatery captures the essence of a classic American burger joint while adding its unique flair.
Food Highlights
- PB&J Burger: A creative twist featuring house-made strawberry jam and peanut butter, striking the perfect balance between sweet and savory.
- Smash Burger: Flavorful and perfectly sized, this burger offers a satisfying bite without overwhelming portions.
- Ghost Fries: Crispy fries with a spicy kick, ideal for those who enjoy a little heat.
- Ginger Beer: A refreshing drink that complements the meal with its zesty flavor.
Atmosphere
The restaurant boasts a unique charm, featuring a glass-enclosed atrium that floods the space with natural light. The blend of an older building’s character and modern design creates a welcoming environment, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family.
Bottom Line
Settle Down Tavern promises a memorable dining experience with its innovative burgers and lively ambiance. Don’t miss the chance to savor the PB&J burger and the ghost fries—both are sure to impress.
Location: 117 S Pinckney St Madison, WI 53703
Sweet Home Wisconsin
Looking for a laid-back burger joint with a friendly atmosphere in Madison? Sweet Home Wisconsin offers a delicious twist on classic American comfort food.
Conveniently located just steps from UnityPoint-Meriter Hospital, this spot caters to both locals and visitors with its variety of mouth-watering burgers, fried favorites, and friendly service.
Whether grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a relaxed evening, this quaint bar and grill will leave you satisfied and eager for more.
Food Highlights
- Patty Melt and Fries: Juicy burger with perfectly crisp, lightly salted fries.
- Garlick Guitar Lick Burger: Packed with bold garlic flavors.
- Fried Cheese Curds: Golden, crispy, and paired with zesty sriracha ranch.
- Phish Fry Sandwich: A crispy, flavorful fish sandwich option.
- Beer Selection: A good variety to complement your meal.
Atmosphere
Expect a cozy vibe with stools lined up by the window overlooking Regent Street. The beautiful patio draped in grapevines offers a relaxed setting for outdoor dining. Perfect for a low-key dinner or a quick lunch, Sweet Home Wisconsin has a welcoming feel for all ages.
Location: 910 Regent St Madison, WI 53715
The Bar Next Door
Don’t sleep on this place.
The Bar Next Door may be tucked away in a building that houses a Super 8 motel, but it’s well worth the visit. This classic Wisconsin bar draws a loyal crowd with its friendly atmosphere, great food, and welcoming service.
Famous for its mouthwatering Smashburger and cheese curds, this spot is a hidden gem that’s becoming a favorite among locals. It’s easy to miss, but once discovered, you’ll keep coming back for the experience.
Food Highlights
- Smashburger: Crispy, flavorful, and a must-try.
- Cheese curds: Among the best in the state.
- Garlic aioli: A standout recommendation by the staff.
- Meatball sub: Tasty but could use more sauce.
- Other menu items: Mussels and egg rolls are worth a try next time!
Bottom Line
For those seeking a great burger, friendly service, and a laid-back atmosphere, The Bar Next Door is a must-visit. You won’t be disappointed by the food or the vibe.
Location: 4506 Lake Cir Windsor, WI 53598