Madison may be known for its cheese, but the pizza scene here is anything but cheesy—except in the best way possible! From classic slices to creative pies, Madison’s pizza joints have something for everyone.
Novanta
Novanta is simply a must-visit for anyone in Madison seeking authentic Neapolitan pizza. This hidden gem offers a slice of Italy with its traditional pizza-making techniques and imported stone ovens. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.
Food Highlights
- Salsiccia Pizza: A personal-sized delight with a thin, scrumptious crust and savory sausage.
- Bufala Pizza: Creamy, mushroomy, with a standout prosciutto.
- Diovala Pizza: A classic pepperoni option with a crispy, bready crust.
- Desserts: Don’t miss the cannoli, tiramisu, or graham cracker cake for a sweet finish.
Atmosphere
The clean and bright interior offers a warm welcome, with ample seating for dine-in customers. Novanta’s open kitchen concept showcases the wood-fired pizza ovens, adding a touch of authenticity to the dining experience. Ordering at the counter keeps the vibe casual, perfect for a relaxed meal.
Bottom Line
For a true taste of Italy in Madison, Novanta is the place to go. With its fresh ingredients, expertly crafted pizzas, and inviting atmosphere, it’s a top choice for pizza lovers.
Location: 2903 University Ave Madison, WI 53705
Grampa’s Pizzeria
For a pizza experience that feels like home, Grampa’s Pizzeria in Madison, WI, delivers comfort with every slice. Located in a cozy, converted house, this spot blends charm with a robust menu, ensuring a memorable dining experience.
Known for its thin crusts and creative toppings, Grampa’s Pizzeria is where locals and visitors alike gather for a relaxed evening with excellent food. Perfect for a casual night out, this pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving a slice of Wisconsin pizza culture.
Food Highlights
- Brassacre Pizza: White sauce with Brussels sprouts and bacon.
- Jabroni Pizza: Thin crust topped with Italian sausage and fresh basil.
- Pork Confit: Tender pork served with bread, mustard sauce, and spicy pickled peppers.
- Beet Salad: A vibrant mix of red and orange beets with greens.
Atmosphere
Grampa’s Pizzeria offers a quaint and inviting atmosphere that feels like dining at a friend’s home. The cozy indoor seating and charming outdoor area make it an ideal spot for any occasion.
Whether inside by the garden-view windows or enjoying the fresh air outside, the ambiance is always welcoming and relaxed.
Bottom Line
Grampa’s Pizzeria is a top choice for anyone seeking a laid-back pizza night in Madison. With its unique menu and cozy setting, it’s a great place to enjoy quality food with family and friends.
Location: 1374 Willamson St Madison, WI 53703
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies
In the heart of Madison, WI, Salvatore’s Tomato Pies beckons pizza lovers with its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering menu. This beloved eatery has garnered a loyal following, thanks to its creative pies and welcoming vibe.
Guests rave about the exceptional flavors and quality ingredients that make each visit memorable. The combination of a cozy lounge and outdoor seating creates the perfect setting for enjoying a delicious meal, whether dining in or taking out.
Food Highlights
- The Walter White Pie: Whole milk mozzarella, spinach, Italian sausage, ricotta, roasted garlic, lemon olive oil, chili flake.
- Fig and Bacon Pizza: A delightful blend of sweet figs and savory bacon that leaves a lasting impression.
- Whipped Ricotta: A cheesy appetizer that ricotta lovers can’t resist.
- Thursday Date Night Special: A three-course meal and a carafe of wine for just $55, perfect for sharing.
Atmosphere
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies features a lively, eclectic decor that exudes a fun, hipster vibe. The indoor space may get a bit loud, but it fosters a warm and inviting environment. Guests can enjoy the comfort of outdoor seating on pleasant evenings, making it an ideal spot for a casual night out.
Bottom Line
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies offers an unforgettable pizza experience that lives up to its reputation. With a diverse menu and inviting atmosphere, it’s a must-visit destination for anyone craving exceptional pizza in Madison.
Location: 912 E Johnson St Madison, WI 53703