Tucked away in downtown Akron, Diamond Deli has become an unexpected sensation that draws lines stretching out the front door during lunch hours.
This unassuming family-run spot proves that sometimes the most extraordinary food experiences come from the most humble beginnings.
With quirky sandwich names and portions that defy physics, this little deli has captured the hearts (and appetites) of locals who consider it nothing short of a treasure.
How Diamond Deli Won Local’s Hearts
Chuck Magilavy and his sister Lynda Slikkerveer purchased Diamond Deli in 1997, transforming what was already a small neighborhood deli into an Akron institution.
The secret to their success lies in their commitment to piling sandwiches impossibly high with premium ingredients and creating a deeply personal experience through their uniquely named menu items.
Each specialty sandwich tells a story connected to family members, regular customers, or local personalities, turning every order into a conversation starter.
The deli’s reputation spread organically through word-of-mouth recommendations from satisfied customers who couldn’t help but rave about sandwiches that required both hands and serious commitment to finish.
Their authentic old-school approach, combined with generous portions and affordable prices (most sandwiches range from $8.50-$11), created a loyal following that considers Diamond Deli the crown jewel of Akron dining.
The family’s dedication to quality ingredients and consistent execution has earned them the #1 restaurant ranking in Akron on TripAdvisor, cementing their status as a local legend. 🏆
Food Highlights
- Chad’s “Wait ‘Til You Hear This Story”: Corned beef and pastrami combo with hot mustard on rye – a powerhouse sandwich that combines the deli’s two signature meats for an unforgettable experience
- Old Bald Guy: Turkey, smoked gouda, bacon, green apple, onion, and sun-dried tomato mayo on grilled ciabatta – named after a beloved regular customer and featuring a perfect sweet-savory balance
- Manny’s B-17: Smoked turkey and ham with honey mustard, tomato, and scallion cream cheese on rye – praised for its amazing scallion cream cheese that elevates this simple combination
- Karen’s “He’s Your Problem Now!”: Roast beef, cheddar, bacon, onion, and horseradish sauce toasted with herbal butter on rye – a spicy kick that packs serious flavor
- Classic Reuben: Mountains of corned beef with Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and homemade Thousand Island dressing on grilled rye – the sandwich that built their reputation with perfectly brined meat
- Broccoli Salad: The legendary side dish that customers specifically rave about – described as “stupendous” and “the bomb” by devoted fans 🥦
ALSO IN AKRON: Super-Groovy Hole in the Wall Pizza Spot 🍕 to Try in Akron, OH
Atmosphere
Step into Diamond Deli and you’ll find yourself in a cozy time capsule filled with sports memorabilia, family photos, and local nostalgia.
Baseball bats, jerseys, and bobbleheads from past decades line the shelves above booths, while loaves of bread and bottled sodas create a charming old-school deli aesthetic.
The cafeteria-style ordering system moves quickly despite the crowds, and the friendly, hardworking staff treats every customer like family.
The recent addition of a colorful mosaic on the building’s exterior, created by local artists, represents the evolution of the space while honoring its community roots.
Despite limited seating, the warm, welcoming vibe makes every visit feel like coming home. 🏠
Bottom Line
Diamond Deli deserves a visit because it offers massive, perfectly crafted sandwiches at unbeatable prices, legendary broccoli salad that’s worth the trip alone, and a genuine family atmosphere that makes you feel like a regular from day one. Plus, you’ll experience Akron’s most beloved local institution. ⭐
Address: 378 S Main St, Akron, OH 44311
📞 (330) 762-5877
🕔 Open Mon-Fri, 9 AM–3 PM (closed weekends)