When pizza lovers in Elk Grove start debating the best slice in town, one name consistently rises to the top. Fat Mike’s Pizza has carved out a legendary reputation since opening its doors in 1992.
Fat Mike’s is the go-to destination for families seeking authentic, hand-crafted pies with a side of genuine community spirit.
This mom-and-pop pizzeria doesn’t just serve food—it serves memories. 🍕
How Fat Mike’s Won Locals’ Hearts
Fat Mike’s didn’t achieve local legend status overnight—it earned every slice of recognition through three decades of unwavering commitment to quality and community.
The family-owned restaurant built its reputation on a simple but powerful motto: “Always Friendly – Always Fresh.”
Every pizza gets made fresh to order with what they proudly call “handfuls” of perfectly blended toppings, ensuring each bite delivers maximum flavor.
But the real secret to their success lies beyond the kitchen—Fat Mike’s became the heartbeat of Elk Grove’s youth athletics scene.
Walk into Fat Mike’s and you’ll immediately notice the back wall plastered with certificates and photos celebrating their decades-long sponsorship of local sports teams.
From Consumnes Little League Baseball for 17 years to Pleasant Grove High School’s multiple sports programs, Fat Mike’s has consistently invested in the community’s future.
The restaurant sponsors everything from Cal Ripken Little League and Elk Grove Girls Softball to Joseph Kerr Wrestling and countless traveling select teams.
This authentic commitment to local youth transformed Fat Mike’s from just another pizza joint into a beloved community institution where generations of families have celebrated victories, commiserated defeats, and created lasting memories. 🏆
Food Highlights
- Mike’s Top Ten Combination: This ultimate crowd-pleaser loads up your crust with pepperoni, onions, green bell peppers, mushrooms, ham, salami, sausage, olives, beef, and extra cheese for a truly indulgent experience that satisfies every craving in one spectacular slice
- Garlic Lover’s Supreme: Features garlic sauce as the base, topped with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, chopped garlic, tomatoes, sausage, and olives, creating a bold and aromatic pizza that garlic enthusiasts absolutely worship
- Buffalo Chicken Style: Built on ranch sauce with buffalo chicken breast, hot sauce, red onion, green onions, and blue cheese crumbles, delivering the perfect balance of creamy coolness and fiery heat
- Pesto Chicken: Combines pesto sauce with tender chicken, feta cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, and bacon, offering a sophisticated Mediterranean-inspired flavor profile that elevates the traditional pizza experience
- Fat Mike’s B.L.T.: Features baby spinach, tomatoes, artichoke hearts, and bacon, transforming the classic sandwich combination into a fresh and satisfying pizza that proves vegetables can be exciting
- Bacon Cheeseburger: Topped with American cheese, beef, more beef, bacon, pickles, and mustard, this creative pie brings all your favorite burger flavors to pizza form with optional lettuce and tomato
Atmosphere
Fat Mike’s captures the essence of a true neighborhood pizza joint with its casual, family-friendly vibe that makes everyone feel at home.
The restaurant features a dedicated mini-arcade area complete with classic games and an air hockey table, creating the perfect entertainment zone for kids while parents enjoy their meal.
With spacious accommodations for large groups and a banquet facility that holds up to 50 people, Fat Mike’s serves as the ideal venue for birthday parties, team celebrations, and family gatherings.
The walls showcasing decades of community involvement tell the story of a restaurant that’s deeply woven into Elk Grove’s fabric, while TVs throughout the dining area ensure you can catch the game while savoring your slice. ⚾
Bottom Line
- Authentic family-owned experience serving the community since 1992 with genuine care and commitment to quality
- Legendary community involvement supporting local youth sports for decades, making every visit feel like supporting your neighbors
- Fresh-made pizzas with generous “handfuls” of toppings that deliver exceptional value and flavor
- Entertainment for all ages with arcade games, spacious seating, and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families
- Consistently ranked among Elk Grove’s best pizza destinations by locals who know quality when they taste it 🎮
Address: 8970 Grant Line Rd, Elk Grove, CA 95624
📞 (916) 686-8543
🕔 Open Sun 11 AM–9:30 PM, Mon 3 PM–9:30 PM, Tue-Thu 11 AM–9:30 PM, Fri-Sat 11 AM–10 PM