The Gessi family anchors this landmark pizzeria to keep 1970s deck baking standards alive.
Foodies drive miles down from Cimarron Hills to devour these mouthwatering, hand-stretched masterpieces daily.
This untouched Palmer Park counter systematically adjusts dough formulas to conquer thin, high-altitude mountain air.
Quick Bite – Leon Gessi New York Pizza, Colorado Springs, CO 🤯
What catches most first-time travelers by surprise is the kitchen’s legendary high-altitude proofing schedule, which systematically alters water temperatures to ensure their signature dough rises perfectly over a mile above sea level.
The menu completely shuns the frozen, mechanized conveyor systems of major national operations, relying instead on heavy stone decks that crisp every hand-stretched base to a textbook golden blister.
Commuters arriving from the residential streets of Security-Widefield or driving up from nearby Fountain crowd the narrow pick-up counter long before the late-night oven shutdowns.
The entire high-energy operation runs on deep El Paso County pride and independent family management, proudly holding its turf on the block as a definitive independent mom and pops and hole in the wall.
The Local Atmosphere – Leon Gessi New York Pizza, Colorado Springs, CO 😍
Nostalgic red-and-white checkered tablecloths cast an instantly comforting, old-school aura across the lively, unpretentious dining room.
Weathered walls are beautifully adorned with decades of local sports team photos and vintage posters celebrating historical Front Range milestones.
A classic glass-fronted ordering counter lets hungry patrons watch skilled pizza bakers casually toss massive dough rounds high into the air.
Signature Bites – Leon Gessi New York Pizza, Colorado Springs, CO 😋
-
New York Style Cheese Slice: The iconic house calling card, featuring an oversized, hand-stretched thin crust that folds perfectly down the middle with zero structural sagging.
-
The Gessi Special Pie: A heavy-duty supreme masterpiece generously loaded to the absolute edge with pepperoni, savory Italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.
-
The Monster Stromboli: A golden, pocket-style baking triumph packing thick layers of ham, salami, pepperoni, and gooey mozzarella inside a crisp pizza dough shell.
-
Scratch-Made Meatball Sub: A comforting mid-day favorite layering plump, house-simmered beef and pork meatballs under rich marinara sauce and a heavy blanket of melted provolone.
-
Sicilian Thick Crust Pizza: A spectacular square-pan alternative boasting a thick, airy, focaccia-like center structure capped with carmelized cheese edges and zesty red sauce.
-
House Calzone: A traditional crescent-shaped pastry stuffed to maximum capacity with a rich, herb-infused blend of creamy ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and savory garlic.
Takeaway Bite – Leon Gessi New York Pizza, Colorado Springs, CO 😎
Bypassing the uninspired, mass-produced delivery conglomerates along the commercial highway grids proves that stubborn baking precision, a legendary thin-air crust recipe, and a permanent home at 1806 Palmer Park Boulevard keep this local treasure operating on its own truly elite level as a classic independent mom and pops and hole in the wall.
📍: 1806 Palmer Park Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80909
📞: (719) 596-7414
🕒: Tue-Sat: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM; Sun-Mon: Closed