How This Couple-Owned Pizza Gem Won Hearts in Longmont, CO

On Longmont’s historic Main Street, Rosalee’s Pizzeria brings authentic East Coast pizza traditions under Western skies.

This couple-owned neighborhood pizzeria has captured hearts with Old World recipes, homemade dough that sells out daily, and that perfect New York-style thin crust locals can’t stop raving about.

From the moment you bite into their legendary crust—so good even non-crust-eaters devour every last bite—you’ll taste the difference that fresh ingredients and traditional methods make. 🍕

How Rosalee’s won Appleton’s hearts

Rosalee’s won over Longmont by delivering something Colorado desperately needed: genuinely authentic East Coast pizza made with integrity and passion.

Since opening their doors, this couple-owned establishment focused on quality over quantity, making everything from scratch daily—dough, sauce, and even their in-house ground Italian sausage.

The proof arrived with every pie: light, crispy crust with perfect char, incredible sauce-to-cheese ratios, and those telltale air pockets that pizza connoisseurs seek.

Kids receive genuine kindness, not just tolerance, making Rosalee’s a true family destination.

The walls display photos and boxes from legendary East Coast joints like Modern Apizza and Sally’s, signaling to pizza aficionados that the owners understand and respect the craft.

Summer nights on the patio became a Longmont tradition, with locals gathering to enjoy spectacular pies paired with local beers.

Food Highlights

• Salami & Basil Square Pizza: The square version of their spicy salami hit, offering more crust-to-topping ratio for those who’ve fallen in love with Rosalee’s dough.

• Classic Cheese Pizza: The foundation of greatness, featuring plum tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano on that legendary crust.

• Margherita Pizza: Fresh and vibrant, this classic combines plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, whole milk mozzarella, fresh basil leaves, and Pecorino Romano.

• Sicilian Square Pizza: This half-pan square feeds groups and features the same quality ingredients on a fluffier, focaccia-like base that’s perfectly crispy on the bottom and airy inside.

• Bacon & Ricotta Pizza: An indulgent combination that proves simple ingredients create magic when done right—crispy bacon provides smoky saltiness while creamy ricotta adds luxurious texture.

• Pepperoni Pizza: New York-style perfection with quality pepperoni that cups and chars slightly in the oven, creating those crispy edges pizza enthusiasts crave.

• White Pizza with Sausage: A popular combination that merges the garlic-ricotta goodness of the white pie with their exceptional house-made sausage.

• House Sausage Pizza: Featuring in-house ground and seasoned Italian sausage, plum tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano. 🌿

Atmosphere

Rosalee’s captures authentic neighborhood pizzeria vibes with its clean, welcoming space that feels genuinely local rather than manufactured.

The walls decorated with photos and memorabilia from legendary East Coast pizza joints create an atmosphere that pizza purists appreciate—it shows respect for the craft.

Front and back patios provide perfect summer dining under Colorado skies, creating the ideal setting for enjoying exceptional pizza with local craft beers.

The vibe remains casual and family-friendly while attracting serious food enthusiasts, making everyone from kids to pizza snobs feel at home. 🌞

Bottom Line

Visit Rosalee’s Pizzeria Longmont for authentic East Coast pizza made with homemade dough, sauce, and in-house ground sausage, legendary thin crust so delicious you’ll eat every last bite, including the edges, and a couple-owned dedication to quality that means they close when the fresh dough sells out.

Patio dining and local beer selections complete the experience. 🌟

Address:

461 Main St, Longmont, CO 80501

📞 (303) 485-5020

🕔 Tue-Sat: 11 AM–8 PM (or until dough sells out) | Sun-Mon: Closed