This Mom-and-Pop Pizza Spot Hides in the Mountain Haven of Cedar Crest, NM

Cedar Crest Spot Shocks Hungry Travelers With Outrageously Delicious Scratch Made Mountain Pizzas

Meat Lovers Pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, New Mexico
Name
Trail Rider
Address
12165 NM-14 Ste B2, Cedar Crest, NM 87008
Hours
Open Mon–Thu & Sun, 8 AM–8:30 PM; Fri–Sat, 8 AM–9:30 PM

Resting along the scenic Turquoise Trail National Scenic Byway, this cherished East Mountain gathering spot delights hungry explorers with hand-tossed pies, roasted Hatch green chile, and hearty mountain hospitality. 🍕

Every scratch-made recipe highlights daily prepared dough, freshly grated whole milk mozzarella, and zesty regional ingredients baked to bubbling perfection. 🍅

Chicken Carbonara Pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, NM
Shelly

How Trail Rider won Cedar Crest’s hearts

East Mountain residents and Albuquerque road-trippers quickly made this friendly neighborhood pizzeria their regular refueling stop along Highway 14 for the most dependable Cedar Crest NM dining. 🌲

The kitchen team earned lasting neighborhood loyalty by preparing dough from scratch every single morning, blending house pizza sauces with vine-ripened tomatoes, and hand-grating whole milk mozzarella daily without ever using pre-shredded cheese. 🧀

Locals deeply appreciate the pizzeria’s thoughtful menu, which offers gluten-free crusts and generous plant-based selections alongside rich carnivorous pies. 🥗

vegan pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, NM
Madeleine

Instead of relying on commercial shortcuts or frozen crusts, the dedicated bakers hand-stretch each pie to order, topping them with slow-braised meats, roasted chiles, and vibrant garden vegetables. 🌿

Word of mouth traveled quickly through Bernalillo and Santa Fe counties as diners praised the generous topping portions, crisp bubbly crusts, and family-friendly prices. 🥖

That steady focus on scratch preparation and community-focused hospitality turned this roadside stop into an indispensable locally-owned restaurant. 🌟

Every pie baked here celebrates the unique flavors that define beloved New Mexico comfort food. 🌶️

Food Highlights

Supreme Pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, New Mexico
Daniel
  • Loaded 8-Topping Supreme Pizza: Robust house-made marinara and whole milk mozzarella piled high with savory Italian sausage, ham, ground beef, spicy pepperoni, onions, sliced mushrooms, green bell peppers, and black olives. 🍕

  • Carne Adovada Pizza: Hand-stretched crust brushed with an olive oil base with tender slow-braised red chile pork, mozzarella, red onions, and cilantro. 🌶️

  • Chicken Carbonara Pizza: Velvety garlic alfredo sauce topped with mozzarella, chicken, bacon crumbles, mushrooms, and Parmesan cheese. 🥓
Meat Lovers Pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, New Mexico
John
  • Meat Lovers Pizza: Hand-stretched dough covered in rich tomato sauce and mozzarella, loaded corner-to-corner with Italian sausage, ground beef, sliced ham, bacon, and pepperoni. 🥩

  • Santa Fe Pizza: Loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, ground beef, green chile, black olives, and optional jalapeños. 🫒

  • Tijeras Pizza: Light olive oil foundation topped with mozzarella, sliced mushrooms, onions, baby spinach, yellow summer squash, pine nuts, and creamy ricotta cheese. 🍄

Taco Pizza at Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, New Mexico
Evelyn
  • Taco Pizza: Angus ground beef, melted cheeses, and mild tomato sauce baked over hand-tossed dough, garnished with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and house salsa. 🌮
  • Cedar Crest Pizza: Olive oil base topped with mozzarella, diced onions, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, and spinach. 🍃

Atmosphere

Wood accents, mountain trail maps, and rustic signage give this dining room a cozy alpine cabin feel. 🌲

Sunlight streams through expansive front windows, revealing stunning views of the surrounding pinyon-juniper foothills. ☀️

interior of Trail Rider in Cedar Crest, NM
Charles

The casual counter-service setup allows hungry travelers to place quick orders while soaking in the relaxed community ambiance. 🚲

Friendly chatter between local mountain regulars and staff fills the warm space with easygoing charm. ✨

Bottom Line

Visit for hand-stretched scratch dough, authentic roasted Hatch green chile, house-smoked specialty meats, and generous community hospitality. 🌟

Address:

12165 NM-14 Ste B2, Cedar Crest, NM 87008
📞 (505) 281-6068
🕔 Open Mon–Thu & Sun, 8 AM–8:30 PM; Fri–Sat, 8 AM–9:30 PM