While most chefs are limited by what they can source from a delivery truck, Chef Martin Firestone gained a massive tactical advantage by building his kitchen directly inside an active butcher market.
This proximity to premium, raw cuts allowed him to pivot away from standard flat-tops and anchor his entire operation around a high-heat, open-flame “Vader” oven.
It is this unique marriage between a master butcher shop and an oak-fired grill that has turned a hidden Peach Street secret into the city’s most famous culinary powerhouse. 🥩🔥
How Firestone’s Conquered the Erie Scene
The success of this mom and pop powerhouse was cemented almost immediately when it was voted the Best New Business in the city.
This rapid rise to local fame is a direct result of Chef Martin Firestone’s three decades of experience and his decision to nestle the kitchen inside Gordon’s Butcher Market.
The result is a seamless connection between the highest quality cuts of meat and a high-heat “Vader” oven that provides a distinct, smoky finish you won’t find anywhere else in the county. 🏆
What really makes this Peach Street destination a NewsBreak sensation is the almost scientific approach to their “Handhelds” and pizzas.
They have mastered a signature smash burger blend of brisket, chuck, and short rib that has locals swearing off national chains for good.
In a city with a rich blue-collar history and an appreciation for honest, scratch-made food, this spot has become the definitive gold standard for upscale-yet-approachable dining. 🌟
Beyond the searing heat of the grill, the atmosphere is sophisticated yet incredibly welcoming for the average Pennsylvanian.
The space somehow feels much larger and more “swank” on the inside than its humble market exterior suggests, creating a perfect backdrop for a social evening.
Whether you are there to browse the beer selection or to sit down for a full-scale feast, you are participating in a local legend that has officially set the bar for the region. 🏠💓
The Lineup & Must-Try Bites
-
The “Gordon’s Smash Burger” is a verifiable local legend. It features a custom 1/3 lb blend of brisket, chuck, and short rib topped with caramelized onions and black pepper Cooper’s cheese on a pretzel roll.
-
The Pickle Pizza is a surprisingly viral hit. This creative pie combines garlic cream sauce and dill pickles with pistachio mortadella and fresh dill for a flavor profile that defies convention.
-
Burrata & Arugula Pizza offers a touch of Italian elegance. It’s finished with chimichurri, shaved prosciutto, and a balsamic drizzle, showcasing the versatility of their fire-roasted crust.
-
Chimi Steak Sandwich brings a bold South American flair. Grilled sirloin is paired with Manchego cheese and chimichurri mayo on a perfectly toasted baguette.
-
Green Chile Mac & Cheese is the ultimate comfort side. It features a zesty green chile cream sauce and parmesan crumbs that provide a sophisticated “kick” to a childhood favorite.
-
Charcuterie Board is the best way to start the night. A hand-selected smorgasbord of cured meats and sausages from the butcher shop paired with Greek olives and spicy mustard.
A Vibe That Feels Like a Discovery
The interior is a blend of modern industrial style and cozy, upscale warmth.
From the flickering flames of the pizza oven to the well-stocked wine and beer area, the energy is consistently “hopping.”
It’s the essential destination for an Erie weekend dinner or a midday escape that feels like a trip to a big-city bistro. 🍷🍕
The Final Verdict on This Erie Legend
If you want to understand why this city is currently buzzing about a butcher-shop kitchen, you must visit Firestone’s. They prove that when you combine 30 years of culinary grit with the best cuts of meat in town, you don’t just open a restaurant—you create an experience. 🥇
📍 4823 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509
📞 (814) 864-5640
🕔 Tue-Thu: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Sun-Mon: Closed