Ok, everyone knows there are loads of great Pizza spots all across Hawaii.
But two legendary establishments, ‘Ili’ili Cash & Carry and J. Dolan’s, have mastered the art of bringing authentic East Coast flavors to the islands.
From ‘Ili’ili’s bodega-style corner store serving up 18-inch New York masterpieces to J. Dolan’s unique blend of Irish pub atmosphere and pizza perfection, these spots have become essential destinations for both locals and visitors seeking their perfect slice of paradise.
‘Ili’ili Cash & Carry
Pizza lovers in Hawaii have discovered their slice of heaven at this Mo’ili’ili neighborhood gem.
This corner store concept brilliantly blends East Coast bodega vibes with Italian market flavors and Japanese convenience store efficiency.
The result? A pizza paradise that’s capturing hearts and taste buds across Honolulu.
Food Highlights:
- Choke Garlic Balls: Addictively chewy, butter-drenched balls of heaven with a crunchy exterior, made even better with optional pepperoni
- 18″ Pepperoni Pizza: A New York-style masterpiece loaded with generous portions of pepperoni
- Italian Hoagie: A massive sandwich stuffed with salami, mortadella, and soppressata
- Off-White Pizza: A unique creation featuring ricotta, mozzarella, and caramelized onions
- Chopped Salad: A fresh mix of lettuce, salumi, pepperoncini, and provolone with house-made Italian dressing
Atmosphere:
The space exudes a cozy, casual vibe with a deli-style counter service setup.
The small but mighty storefront maintains a constant buzz of happy customers picking up their orders.
Why It’s One of the Best in Hawaii:
The restaurant has mastered the art of authentic East Coast-style pizza in paradise.
Their commitment to quality ingredients, house-baked bread, and consistently excellent execution makes it a standout destination for both locals and tourists.
The combination of reasonable prices and generous portions keeps customers coming back for more.
Address: 2065 S Beretania St, Honolulu, HI 96826
PIZZA STONE FOR GRILL AND OVEN: Our very best pizza stone formulated from toughened porous cordierite stone. FDA safe and heat resistant up to 1112°f(600℃).
J. Dolan’s
When a New York-style pizzeria meets an Irish pub in the heart of Honolulu’s Chinatown, magic happens.
J. Dolan’s has created quite the buzz with its unique fusion of East Coast pizza expertise and Hawaiian hospitality.
The restaurant now boasts two locations – the original downtown spot and a newer Kahala location, both serving up some of the most talked-about pies on the island.
Food Highlights:
- Spinach and Garlic Pie: A best-seller featuring East Coast ricotta, mozzarella, fresh spinach, and aromatic garlic
- The Giacomo: A meat lover’s dream loaded with sausage, pepperoni, and olives
- Kalua Pork Pizza: A Hawaiian twist featuring local cabbage and spicy Kilauea Fire Sauce
- Jersey White Pie: A creamy blend of cheeses that pays homage to East Coast roots
- Boardwalk Pie: A savory combination of Italian sausage, onions, peppers, and garlic
Atmosphere:
The restaurant sports a polished yet relaxed vibe with a beautiful 1940s Koa wood bar as its centerpiece.
The space offers both indoor and outdoor seating, with a comfortable neighborhood pub feel that maintains distinct Hawaiian character.
TVs throughout make it perfect for catching games, while the open-air setting keeps things cool and inviting.
Why It’s One of the Best in Hawaii:
J. Dolan’s combines the best of both worlds – authentic East Coast pizza craftsmanship with local Hawaiian ingredients and hospitality.
The diverse clientele of business professionals, students, and military personnel creates an energetic atmosphere that’s welcoming to all.
Address: 4210 Waialae Ave, Honolulu, HI 96816 (Kahala location)
1147 Bethel St, Honolulu, HI 96813 (Downtown location)