South Carolina’s pizza scene thrives where tradition meets rebellion!
The Obstinate Daughter on Sullivan’s Island slings wood-fired masterpieces like its Old Danger pie—smoked tomato sauce colliding with spicy soppressata and honey drizzle.
In West Columbia, Cucinella’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice delivers New York-style crunch crowned with sweet figs, prosciutto, and house-churned gelato.
Both redefine pie perfection with bold flavors and zero pretense.
🍕 The Obstinate Daughter
This pizzeria isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a flavor rebellion 🌊🔥.
With wood-fired pies that slap harder than a Lowcountry tide and a vibe that’s equal parts coastal chill and unapologetic energy, The Obstinate Daughter turns pizza night into a full-blown adventure.
Think crackling crusts, locally caught seafood, and a menu that winks at Southern tradition while flipping it the bird 🍕⚡.
Food Highlights
- Old Danger Pizza: Smoked tomato sauce, spicy soppressata, and honey drizzle create a sweet-heat riot. Yelp reviewers pledge loyalty to this fiery favorite.
- Moultrie Pizza: Pepperoni, shiitake mushrooms, and Mepkin Abbey mozzarella team up for a umami-packed knockout26.
- Rutledge Pizza: Fresh clams, bacon, and lemon zest—a briny, smoky love letter to the coast.
- Ricotta Gnocchi: Pillowy dumplings drenched in short rib ragu—comfort food that wears combat boots14.
Atmosphere
Sunlight floods the nautical-chic dining room 🪐, where exposed beams and an open kitchen buzz with energy.
Grab a seat at the bar for next-level people-watching or snag a patio table to spy on island life below.
Staff here treat you like a regular—even if it’s your first rodeo 🤠.
Why It’s One of the Best in South Carolina
They’re not just slinging dough—they’re rewriting pizza rules with hyper-local ingredients and zero pretension.
Where else can you devour a clam-topped pie while learning about Revolutionary War heroines?
Post-meal beach strolls optional (but highly recommended) 🌴.
Address: 2063 Middle St, Sullivan’s Island, SC 29482
🍕 Cucinella’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice
Craving a slice of pure joy in West Columbia? Cucinella’s Pizzeria & Italian Ice delivers New York-style magic with a Southern twist 🎉✨.
This family-owned hotspot whips up scratch-made pies that’ll make your taste buds dance—think crispy crusts, zesty sauces, and toppings so fresh they practically sing 🍅🧀.
Add gelato-topped Italian ice and garlic knots dripping with cheesy goodness, and you’ve got a meal that’s basically a happiness explosion 🚀.
Food Highlights
- Cucinella’s House Pie: A carnivore’s dream with pepperoni, Italian sausage, banana peppers, and fresh mozzarella—bold flavors that reviewers call “out of this world” 🍖🔥.
- Pig & Fig Pizza: Sweet figs, salty prosciutto, and peppery arugula unite under a balsamic glaze drizzle. Sweet-savory perfection for adventurous eaters 🐷🍯.
- Margherita Pizza: Garlic-olive oil base, fresh basil, and Roma tomatoes—a bright, classic pie that’s “insanely good” (according to Google reviewers) 🌿🍅.
- Flamethrower Pizza: Bacon, jalapeños, hot cherry peppers, and hot honey crank up the heat. Spice lovers call it “fiery genius” 🌶️🔥.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Tangy buffalo sauce meets creamy ranch or blue cheese. “Better than any chain pizza,” say regulars 🐔💙.
Atmosphere
Vibrant and welcoming, with checkered tables and the aroma of garlic knots wafting through the air.
Staff greet regulars by name, and the retro-meets-modern vibe keeps families and foodies coming back.
Why It’s One of the Best in South Carolina
Using 90-year-old family recipes from Rochester, NY, Cucinella’s nails the crispy-yet-chewy crust that New York transplants swear by.
Their homemade gelato and rotating “Pie of the Week” keep menus exciting.
Open Tue-Sat 11AM-9PM, Sun 11AM-8PM 🕚🍴
Address: 2250 Sunset Blvd – Suite M, West Columbia, SC