New Rochelle’s pizza scene is a delicious blend of old-world tradition and modern innovation. From coal-fired brick ovens at Pizzeria La Rosa to the family recipes at Alfredo’s Pizza Cafe, this Westchester gem offers everything from classic Neapolitan to unique specialty pies that will satisfy both purists and adventurous eaters alike.
Pizza da Michelino
Pizza lovers, rejoice! A mobile wood-fired pizzeria has revolutionized the New York pizza scene. Pizza da Michelino brings authentic Napoletana-style pizza directly to hungry customers across Westchester County, NYC, and Charleston, SC.
Owner Michael Alfano’s passion for Italian cuisine, inspired by travels with his Nonna to Sicily, shines through in every perfectly crafted pie that emerges from their imported Italian wood-fired oven.
Food Highlights
- Spicy Mike: A signature creation featuring hot soppressata drizzled with hot honey
- Braised Beef Short Rib: Luxuriously topped with vodka sauce
- Prosciutto di Parma: Enhanced with shaved Moliterno al Tartufo
- Speck Pizza: Finished with homemade pistacchio pesto
- Butler Pizza: Features bacon, kale, cremini mushrooms, and caramelized onions
Atmosphere
The mobile pizzeria experience creates an intimate and engaging atmosphere at every location. The beautifully decorated imported wood-fired oven serves as the centerpiece, where guests can watch their pizzas being crafted with precision.
Bottom Line
Pizza da Michelino delivers an authentic Italian pizza experience that rivals what you’d find in Naples. The combination of high-quality ingredients, traditional techniques, and the owner’s genuine passion makes this mobile pizzeria a must-visit for serious pizza enthusiasts.
Address: Mobile throughout Westchester County, NYC, & Charleston, SC
![Mastering Pizza: The Art and Practice of Handmade Pizza, Focaccia, and Calzone [A Cookbook]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61s+vTX2a4L._SL500_.jpg)
Pizzeria La Rosa
Pizza lovers, rejoice! In the heart of New Rochelle, NY, a 100-year-old converted bakery has transformed into one of Westchester’s most beloved pizza destinations. Pizzeria La Rosa, opened in 2017 by local chef Matt DiGesu, fires up incredible wood-burning pizzas in their restored 1924 Peterson oven that reaches a scorching 850 degrees.
This historic oven creates pizzas with an unmistakable smoky flavor in just 2-3 minutes.
Food Highlights
- Margherita Pizza: A perfect blend of San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil with an exceptionally crispy crust
- Vodka Pizza: Tangy and garlicky with a rich, smooth tomato sauce that keeps customers coming back
- Gold Rush Wings: A must-try appetizer that rivals the best wing spots in the area
- Lemon Ricotta Italian Doughnuts: Piping hot zeppole that create friendly battles over who gets the last one
Atmosphere
The restaurant combines Brooklyn hipster vibes with suburban comfort, featuring three distinct dining rooms including a bar area with big-screen TVs.
The space welcomes everyone from families with kids to date-night couples, creating a warm, rustic atmosphere that feels both modern and homey.
Bottom Line
With its historic wood-fired oven, exceptional pizza crust, and welcoming vibe, Pizzeria La Rosa delivers an authentic Italian-American experience that makes it worth the trip to New Rochelle. The combination of traditional techniques and fresh ingredients creates pizza magic that keeps locals coming back and attracts visitors from across the region.
Address: 12 Russell Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801Citations:
Pizza Fenice
Pizza lovers, rejoice! A World Pizza Champion has brought his masterful craft to Pelham, NY. Chef John Gristina’s Pizza Fenice delivers an extraordinary range of pizza styles that will make your taste buds dance with joy.
From traditional New York slices to creative specialty pies, this cozy spot has quickly become one of Westchester County’s most talked-about pizzerias, earning rave reviews for its exceptional quality and innovative combinations.
Food Highlights
- Detroit Red: A thick, crunchy crust topped with premium cheese and a perfect layer of sauce, making it one of the best Detroit-style pizzas in the region
- Brooklyn Sicilian: Features a perfectly crafted reverse cheese-sauce order with garlic on top, delivering a harmonious blend of flavors
- Hot Honey Ricotta Pepperoni: A crowd favorite combining sweet and spicy elements with creamy ricotta
- Triple Grandma: An innovative creation featuring pesto, vodka sauce, and marinara for a flavor explosion
- White Pizza: A masterful blend of cheeses that keeps customers coming back for more
Atmosphere
The intimate space features just two tables, creating a charming neighborhood vibe. The warm, welcoming staff and Chef John’s personable nature make every visit feel special. A playful leg lamp in the window adds character to this unpretentious gem.
Bottom Line
Pizza Fenice delivers some of the finest pizza craftsmanship in Westchester County, offering both traditional excellence and creative innovations that make it worth the trip from anywhere in the region.
Address: 304 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803