You know a spot is special when locals happily wait for a table on a random Tuesday night.
At Anthonino’s Taverna on The Hill, regulars pile in for big plates of Greek-Italian comfort food, cold drinks, and easy conversation.
The vibe is warm, lively, and unpretentious, the kind of place where you relax the moment you sit down.
If you love pizza, pasta, and hearty, scratch-made classics, this is exactly the kind of neighborhood tavern you want in your life.
How Anthonino’s Taverna won locals’ hearts
Anthonino’s Taverna won locals over by serving Greek-Italian comfort food that feels familiar but never boring.
The family-owned spot leans into its heritage, mixing Italian red-sauce favorites with Greek-inspired dishes so everyone at the table finds something they love.
Their house-made toasted ravioli became a legend in St. Louis, turning first-time visitors into repeat customers.
Food lovers appreciate that pasta is made fresh, with egg- and semolina-heavy dough that gives every bite a richer, more satisfying texture.
The kitchen keeps things honest: scratch-made sauces, quality ingredients, and generous portions that feel like someone’s cooking for you, not just serving you.
Locals trust that their favorite dish tastes the same every visit, which is huge when you have regulars eating there week after week.
The historic bar, original floors, and tin ceiling create a cozy backdrop that feels rooted in the neighborhood, not manufactured.
As demand grew, the spacious back dining room and covered patio gave families and big groups room to celebrate without losing that intimate tavern feel.
Word-of-mouth, glowing online reviews, and TV attention for their toasted ravioli helped spread the buzz beyond The Hill.
Still, the restaurant keeps a laid-back, neighborhood energy, so visitors feel like they’re stepping into a local secret, not a tourist trap.
People keep coming back because the combo of comforting food, fair prices, and friendly service feels easy and dependable.
In the end, they didn’t chase trends – they cooked with care, treated people well, and let the community do the talking.
Food Highlights
-
Handmade Toasted Ravioli: Crispy, golden, house-made ravioli served with rich, scratch-made marinara. A must-order starter and one of St. Louis’ most popular versions. Perfect for sharing… or not. 🥟
-
Fresh Pasta with Marinara: Fresh, egg- and semolina-based pasta with a soft, tender bite. Tossed in a slow-simmered marinara that highlights simple, comforting flavors done right. 🍝
-
Bolognese Pasta: Fresh pasta topped with a hearty, meaty Bolognese sauce. A classic, filling choice that’s rich, savory, and satisfying.
-
House Pizza (Classic Pies): Well-balanced pizzas with a sturdy crust and quality toppings. A local favorite for sharing or takeout, especially for casual nights. 🍕
-
Specialty or Topped Pizzas: Creative topping combos with plenty of cheese, meats, and fresh veggies. Great for mixing slices and sharing with friends.
-
Cioppino with Pasta on the Side: A bold seafood stew with shrimp, crab, and salmon in tomato broth, served with fresh pasta on the side. Comforting with a twist. 🦐
-
Greek-Style Romaine Salad (With Feta and Kalamata Olives): Crisp romaine with feta, olives, red onion, and creamy Greek dressing. A fresh, tangy side that balances richer dishes. 🥗
Atmosphere
The atmosphere at Anthonino’s Taverna is cozy, lively, and welcoming, like a classic neighborhood bar that happens to serve seriously good food.
You’ll notice the historic bar, original wood floors, and tin ceiling, which give the space a warm, lived-in character that feels instantly comfortable.
The expanded dining room and covered patio make it easy to bring a crowd, while the friendly staff keeps the mood relaxed, chatty, and very local.
It’s the kind of place where you feel just as at home on date night as you do at a big family dinner.
Bottom Line
Come to Anthonino’s Taverna for fresh pasta, legendary toasted ravioli, and crowd-pleasing pizza that delivers real comfort on every plate.
Stay for the easygoing tavern energy, neighborhood charm, and consistent, from-scratch cooking that keeps St. Louis locals coming back again and again.
Address: 2225 Macklind Ave, Saint Louis, MO 63110
📞 (314) 773-4455
🕔 Open Mon-Sat 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM | Sun Closed