Newport News may not be Italy, but its pizza scene is causing quite a stir. From classic New York-style slices to innovative gourmet pies, this coastal Virginia city serves up a slice of heaven for every palate.
Newcomers and long-time locals alike are falling head over heels for these dough-slinging hotspots that are redefining pizza perfection.
Bird Girl Bottle Shop
Located in Newport News, VA, Bird Girl Bottle Shop offers a unique blend of delightful pizzas and a welcoming atmosphere. This charming spot, housed in a converted historic home, has quickly become a beloved local hangout.
With an impressive selection of craft beers and wines, it caters to every palate. The cozy outdoor patio, adorned with string lights, creates a perfect backdrop for enjoying exceptional food and drinks.
Food Highlights
- Specialty Pizzas: Each week features two creative options, including the intriguing Sharpie Tattoo with egg and a hint of sweetness, and the refreshing Take Me Home, reminiscent of a Greek pizza.
- Build-Your-Own Pizza: Guests can customize their cheese pizza with fresh ingredients.
- Calzone Special: Available at lunch, offering cheese or pepperoni options, plus additional toppings upon request.
- Cauliflower Crust: A gluten-conscious alternative that doesn’t compromise on flavor.
Atmosphere
Bird Girl Bottle Shop fosters a community vibe with board games, outdoor games like cornhole, and a fire pit for cozy gatherings. The friendly staff creates a welcoming environment, making every visit feel like coming home.
Bottom Line
For anyone seeking a memorable dining experience, Bird Girl Bottle Shop is a must-visit. Its innovative pizzas, extensive drink selection, and inviting atmosphere make it the perfect spot for families and friends alike.
Location: 100 Hopkins St Newport News, VA 23601
Benny Cantiere’s
Benny Cantiere’s in Newport News, VA, promises an unforgettable pizza experience that combines generous portions with delightful flavors. Known for its oversized slices reminiscent of New York style, this eatery offers a monthly rotating menu featuring unique toppings.
The friendly staff ensures quick service, making it an ideal spot for a satisfying lunch or a casual dinner. With its local charm and vibrant atmosphere, Benny Cantiere’s is a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Food Highlights
- Gigantic Pizza Slices: Each slice is as big as your face, perfect for a hearty meal.
- Monthly Specials: Enjoy unique flavor combinations that change regularly, keeping the menu exciting.
- Affordable Pricing: With slices priced around $5-$7, diners receive excellent value for their money.
- Quality Ingredients: The crust strikes a perfect balance—neither too stiff nor too soft—allowing for optimal topping enjoyment.
Atmosphere
The décor at Benny Cantiere’s is simple yet fun, infused with local flair that creates a welcoming vibe. The restaurant maintains a clean and organized space, making it a pleasant spot to enjoy a meal.
Bottom Line
Benny Cantiere’s offers not only enormous, delicious slices but also a friendly atmosphere that keeps customers coming back. For anyone craving authentic New York-style pizza in Newport News, this restaurant is a must-try!
Location: 212 23rd St Ste 200 Newport News, VA 23607
The Original Pizza Sam
In Newport News, VA, The Original Pizza Sam offers a delightful experience for pizza lovers and casual diners alike.
With a menu that features classic New York-style pizza and hearty Italian favorites, it’s a destination that promises satisfaction for every palate.
Food Highlights
- Garlic Knots: These buttery, garlic-infused bites are a must-try, often praised for their authentic taste.
- Margarita Pizza: A generous slice bursting with fresh ingredients, perfect for judging any pizza place.
- Veggie Pizza: Loaded with a vibrant assortment of vegetables, this pizza is a feast for both the eyes and the taste buds.
- Lasagna Pizza: A unique twist that combines the best of two beloved dishes.
- Cheesecake and Ice Cream Sandwiches: Sweet treats that provide a perfect ending to your meal.
Atmosphere
The ambiance at The Original Pizza Sam radiates warmth and friendliness. The spacious dining area features walls decorated with the owners’ family history, adding a personal touch.
Guests can watch their meals being prepared in the open kitchen, where the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air. The vibe is casual yet inviting, making it an ideal spot for families and friends.
Bottom Line
For an unforgettable pizza experience in Newport News, The Original Pizza Sam is a must-visit. With its delicious food, friendly service, and welcoming atmosphere, it’s a hidden gem that deserves attention.
Location: 15392 Warwick Blvd Newport News, VA 23608