When it comes to pizza, Tallahassee has more than just a few slices of heaven to offer. If you’re a fan of the classic Margherita or adventurous toppings that push the pizza envelope, these local spots have something hot and fresh that’ll make you rethink your usual order.
Bagigio’s
Bagigio’s in Tallahassee offers an exceptional dining experience that brings the flavors of Italy to the heart of Florida. This family-owned gem delights pizza enthusiasts with its authentic Italian-style pizzas, fresh salads, and homemade gelato.
Guests can enjoy a cozy atmosphere while savoring dishes made from the finest ingredients. With the recent addition of beer and wine, Bagigio’s has become a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a delightful meal.
Food Highlights
- Wood-Fired Pizzas: Each pizza features a light, crispy crust, with options like the savory Americana and the fresh Deluxe loaded with vegetables.
- Margarita Pie: A crowd favorite, this pizza boasts a tangy sauce and a perfect balance of flavors, showcasing the quality of ingredients.
- Supreme Pizza: Topped with olives, baby pepperoni, onions, Italian sausage, and mushrooms, this pizza is a delicious blend of tastes without overwhelming saltiness.
- Caesar Salad: Fresh, crispy lettuce and croutons paired with a perfectly balanced dressing make this salad a great side.
- Homemade Gelato: The mango gelato offers a refreshing sweetness, while the tiramisu is a light and creamy finish to the meal.
Atmosphere
Bagigio’s presents a cozy and inviting ambiance, ideal for casual meals with friends or family. The attentive staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, making every visit memorable.
Bottom Line
For those in search of quality pizza and a warm atmosphere, Bagigio’s is a destination worth exploring. Its commitment to fresh ingredients and exceptional service guarantees a delightful experience.
Location: 8954 Woodville Hwy Tallahassee, FL 32305
Dave’s Pizza Garage
In the heart of Tallahassee, Dave’s Pizza Garage offers an unforgettable pizza experience that beckons locals and visitors alike. With a vibrant atmosphere and a menu brimming with unique flavors, this restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious, high-quality pizza.
From the moment you step in, the friendly service and inviting decor create a warm environment that enhances every meal.
Food Highlights
- Bradley’s Sausage Pizza: A crowd favorite, loaded with savory sausage and melty cheese.
- Bradley’s Devil Dog Pizza: A daring choice for adventurous eaters, packed with bold flavors.
- Personal Pan Pepperoni Pizza: Perfectly cooked with a crispy crust and generous toppings.
- Roast Beef on Kimmelwick Roll: A delightful nod to Buffalo, delivering a taste of the North.
- Lunch Special: An affordable option featuring a personal pizza, cookie, and drink for around $10.
Atmosphere
The spacious outdoor dining area is ideal for enjoying meals al fresco, while the cozy interior features booths and tables that cater to families and groups. Kid-friendly activities and a dedicated menu ensure a welcoming experience for guests of all ages.
Bottom Line
Dave’s Pizza Garage exemplifies why pizza lovers should make the trip to Tallahassee. With exceptional flavors, friendly service, and a relaxed atmosphere, it promises a memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Location: 2887 Kerry Forest Pkwy Ste 1 Tallahassee, FL 32312
Solle’s Italian
Looking for authentic Italian pizza in Tallahassee? Solle’s Italian is the spot to try. This cozy eatery has a reputation for crafting delicious pizzas that keep locals and visitors coming back.
Known for their attention to detail and commitment to quality, Solle’s offers a variety of options that cater to both traditional pizza lovers and those seeking something a bit more unique. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s no wonder this place has earned rave reviews.
Food Highlights
- 20-Inch Pizza: Thin crust, half cheese, half pepperoni, perfectly balanced sauce.
- Stromboli: Filled with pepperoni, anchovies, mushrooms, and onions; a must-try.
- Sicilian Pizza: Puffy, crisp edges, topped with mushroom, sausage, and onions.
- White Pizza: Rich flavor, perfectly seasoned.
- Pasta with Red Sauce: Moist meatballs, flavorful sauce, kid-approved.
Atmosphere
Solle’s Italian offers a small, intimate setting that adds to its charm. Despite its limited parking and size, the warm and inviting environment makes it a great spot for a cozy meal. The staff is always ready to assist, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
Bottom Line
Solle’s Italian is well worth the visit for anyone craving delicious, authentic pizza in Tallahassee. Whether dining in or ordering for delivery, the quality and taste are consistently impressive.
Location: 4019 Fred George Rd Tallahassee, FL 32303