When a local restaurant starts attracting customers who don’t mind traveling across town for a burger, you know something special is happening.
Beth’s Burger Bar in Lake Mary has become a prime example of how authentic flavors and genuine hospitality create a dining experience that transforms first-time visitors into loyal regulars. 🍔
How Beth’s won local’s hearts
Beth Steele, a New York native who made Orlando her home, experienced the same frustration many burger enthusiasts face: restaurants that promise customization but deliver disappointment.
Fed up with lukewarm patties and limited options, Beth decided to create the perfect burger experience herself. She opened her first location in downtown Orlando in December 2012, then expanded to Lake Mary where she could implement her vision of a highly customizable build-a-burger menu with fresh daily ingredients.
The secret to Beth’s success lies in her unwavering commitment to quality. Every burger is hand-pattied fresh rather than using pre-formed patties, and the restaurant receives daily bun deliveries from a local bakery to ensure optimal freshness.
This attention to detail, combined with creative signature options like the beloved Peanut Butter Burger and the Mac & Cheese Burger, has earned Beth’s Burger Bar multiple “Best Burger in Orlando” awards from Orlando Magazine (2016-2022), plus recognition as “Best Local Burger” by Orlando Local News.
What truly sets Beth’s apart is the personal touch Beth brings to every location. She maintains a regular presence at each restaurant, creating genuine connections with customers who now specifically seek her out.
Her friendly, approachable personality has made her a local celebrity – customers frequently request photos and even invite her to birthday celebrations.
Youtuber tries the Double D Challange
This authentic relationship-building, combined with her restaurant’s motto “Proof that one girl can beat five guys!” has transformed Beth’s Burger Bar from a simple burger joint into a community gathering place.
Food Highlights
- The Peanut Butter Burger: Features cheddar cheese, grilled onions, A1 sauce, and peanut butter sauce – this unusual combination has become the restaurant’s best-seller and consistently surprises skeptics who try it on dares from friends
- Mac & Cheese Burger: Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, and white cheddar mac & cheese, this indulgent creation ranks as the **#1 most likeitem on delivery platforms with a 91% approval rating
- Western Burger: A crowd-pleaser featuring pepper-jack cheese, onion rings, BBQ sauce, and jalapeños that delivers the perfect balance of smoky and spicy flavors
- Black Jack Burger: Features blackened seasoning, pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and thousand Island dressing – this premium option boasts an impressive 93% customer satisfaction rate
- The Morning Burger: A breakfast-inspired creation with cheddar cheese, bacon, and a fried egg that appeals to customers any time of day
- Double D Challenge: A massive four-patty burger topped with eight slices of bacon, five different cheeses, and numerous toppings that challenges competitive eaters to finish within 10 minutes for a free t-shirt
Atmosphere
Beth’s Burger Bar Lake Mary creates a welcoming family atmosphere with its spacious indoor seating and large covered outdoor patio.
The restaurant features distinctive red hand-shaped chairs flanking the entrance, while the bright red color scheme throughout the space creates an energetic, playful vibe.
The outdoor area includes oversized games and activities for children, making it an ideal destination for families.
Pet-friendly outdoor seating accommodates furry companions, while the fast-casual ordering system keeps service quick and efficient.
The funky diner aesthetic appeals to customers seeking both a nostalgic feel and modern comfort. 🎮
ALSO IN ORLANDO: The Top Thrift & Vintage Shops in Orlando, FL
Bottom Line
- Award-winning burgers with multiple recognitions as Orlando’s best, ensuring consistently high quality that exceeds expectations
- Unmatched customization options allowing customers to build their perfect burger with fresh, daily ingredients and creative topping combinations
- Exceptional value with generous portions and reasonable prices that won’t break the budget, especially compared to rapidly increasing fast-food costs
- Family-friendly environment featuring outdoor games, pet-friendly seating, and a welcoming atmosphere perfect for any occasion
- Personal touch from owner Beth Steele, who maintains regular presence and builds genuine relationships with customers, creating a true community experience
Address: 223 Wheelhouse Ln, Suite 1121, Lake Mary, FL 32746
📞 (407) 716-2272
🕔 Mon-Thu: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM, Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM–10:00 PM, Sun: 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
Meta Description: Discover why Beth’s Burger Bar in Lake Mary FL has won locals’ hearts with award-winning custom burgers, fresh daily ingredients! 🍔