Downtown Muncie got a major upgrade when this small-batch slider shop opened its doors, proving that sometimes the best things come in small packages. 🍔
Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co brings the classic slider experience to Indiana with perfectly grilled mini burgers, crispy fries dusted with signature “Stardust” seasoning, and the legendary Comet sauce that has customers raving.
With a simple menu executed to perfection, this spot proves the philosophy that when you keep it simple and do it right, magic happens—and locals are giving it 9.5 to 10 out of 10 ratings.
How Comet’s won Muncie hearts
Comets Downtown succeeded by focusing on a deliberately limited menu and executing every single item to perfection.
The decision to offer just a few items rather than an overwhelming menu allowed the kitchen to nail the fundamentals—great sliders, perfect fries, and an addictive sauce that ties everything together. 👨🍳
The Comet sauce became an instant legend among Muncie foodies.
Customers consistently recommend dipping both your sliders and fries in the Comet sauce, describing it as “phenomenal” and the secret ingredient that elevates every bite from good to extraordinary.
The Supernova Combo with grilled onions and bacon quickly became the signature order that food reviewers rate 9.5 to 10 out of 10, with the perfectly seasoned patties, fresh toppings, and that signature sauce creating an unforgettable flavor combination. 🌟
Exceptional hospitality set Comets apart from typical fast-casual spots.
The owners personally check on customers, make helpful suggestions, and even turn on music to enhance the dining experience—that personal touch transforms a quick meal into something memorable.
The “Stardust” seasoning on the fries became another signature element that keeps people coming back.
Multiple reviewers mention these perfectly seasoned, crispy fries as being just as good as the burgers themselves. 🍟
Curbside delivery service added convenience without sacrificing quality.
Comets brings food directly to your car, making it easy for busy families and professionals to grab lunch or dinner without leaving their vehicles—though the service is so attentive some customers joke they visit “a little too much.”
The Northern Star Combo and Experience Combo gave customers options while maintaining the focused menu approach—each combo includes two sliders with fries, delivering filling portions despite the smaller burger size.
Perhaps most impressively, Comets built a reputation so strong that visitors from Tennessee specifically search Muncie Facebook groups for recommendations, discover Comets, and wish they could return the next day before heading home. ✨
The dessert program added an unexpected sweet finish.
Reviewers rave about strawberry cheesecake parfaits that perfectly complement the savory sliders, showing the restaurant’s commitment to excellence extends beyond just burgers.
Food Highlights
Supernova Combo: This fan-favorite order includes two sliders with bacon, grilled onions, cheese, and Comet sauce, plus fries dusted with Stardust seasoning—customers rate it 9.5 to 10 out of 10 and call it “fire.” 🔥
Northern Star Combo: The signature offering features two perfectly grilled sliders paired with signature Comet sauce and fries—it’s the classic experience that showcases why Comets has become beloved.
Experience Combo: Another popular choice that delivers two sliders with fries, allowing customers to customize their order while maintaining the quality that makes Comets special.
Stardust Fries: These legendary fries come dusted with the restaurant’s signature Stardust seasoning and are crispy, perfectly seasoned, and absolutely addictive when dipped in Comet sauce—reviewers say they’re “seasoned to perfection.” 🍟
Comet Sauce: The secret weapon that customers insist you dip both your sliders and fries into—this proprietary sauce is what makes the whole experience come together and keeps people craving more.
Strawberry Cheesecake Parfait: This delightful dessert provides the perfect sweet finish to your meal, with layers of creamy cheesecake and fresh strawberries that earn specific praise from satisfied diners. 🍓
Atmosphere
Comets Downtown offers a casual, welcoming environment perfect for quick lunches or relaxed dinners.
The owners create a friendly, attentive atmosphere where they personally check on guests and even turn on music to enhance the dining experience.
Located at 1231 S Walnut Street in downtown Muncie, the restaurant offers both dine-in and convenient curbside service for maximum flexibility.
The vibe is unpretentious and fun, with a simple menu displayed clearly and a clean space that keeps the focus squarely on delivering exceptional sliders and fries. 🎵
Bottom Line
Visit Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co for perfectly grilled sliders with fresh toppings executed to perfection, legendary Comet sauce that customers insist you dip everything into, signature Stardust fries seasoned to perfection, exceptional personal hospitality from owners who check on every table, simple focused menu that does everything right, convenient curbside service, and ratings of 9.5 to 10 out of 10 from satisfied customers. 🎯
Address: Comets Downtown Sliders & Fries Co
1231 S Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47302
📞 (765) 266-5878
🕔 Tue-Fri, 11:00 AM–8:00 PM | Sat-Sun, 11:00 AM–3:30 PM (Closed Mon)