If you’ve ever wished you could teleport a legit New York slice straight into East Nashville, this is your sign to head to Five Points Pizza.
This is the spot locals rave about for thin, foldable slices that stay firm in the middle, crispy at the edge, and loaded with just the right amount of cheese.
It’s the kind of place where one slice feels like a full event, and a whole pie feels like a life choice you absolutely don’t regret. 😋
How they won local’s hearts
Five Points Pizza won over Nashville by doing something deceptively simple: respecting New York-style craft without turning it into a gimmick.
Locals fell hard for those rigid, foldable slices that don’t flop, with a crust that crackles on the outside but still has that satisfying chew in every bite.
People who usually struggle with heavy, over-processed dough rave about how they can actually enjoy this pizza without feeling wrecked afterward, which says a lot about the care going into their dough.
Then there’s the balance factor—sauce and cheese in perfect harmony, never greasy chaos or bland cardboard, which is a lot rarer than it should be.
The habanero cream pie helped seal their legend status, proving they’re not just copying New York but elevating it with rich, spicy, smart flavor combos that still respect the style. 🌶️
Families, couples, and solo slice hunters turned this Woodland Street spot into a weekly ritual, thanks to consistent quality across dine-in, pickup, and even big catering orders.
Add their almost-too-good-to-be-true happy hour deal—a giant slice and a cider that doesn’t obliterate your wallet—and suddenly you’ve got a neighborhood favorite that people actually build their schedules around.
In a city packed with pizza options, Five Points earned loyalty by delivering the kind of pizza people crave again the second they finish the last crust.
Food Highlights
- Old World Pizza: Classic New York-style done right, with thin, crisp crust, balanced sauce, and cheese that hits that golden middle of salty, tangy, and melty. 🍕
- Habanero Cream Pie: A rich, creamy base with legit spicy habanero heat and fresh toppings that wake up your taste buds without blowing them out—a must-order for spice fans. 🌶️
- Prosciutto and Basil: Simple ingredients get the star treatment here; salty prosciutto and fresh basil ride on that perfect crust, proving that when the base is good, you don’t need to overcomplicate the toppings. 🌿
- Meatball Pizza: Hearty meatballs layered over their signature thin crust give you all the comfort of a heavy meat pizza without feeling overloaded, ideal for those who want flavor and balance in the same bite. 🍖
- Pizza Bianca: A sauce-less white pie that lets the dough, cheese, and toppings shine on their own, perfect for anyone who loves creamy, garlicky, ultra-satisfying slices without a drop of red. 🧀
- Garlic Knots: Soft and pillowy on the inside with crisp, golden edges on the outside, drenched in garlic and served with marinara that complements instead of overpowering—the kind of side you’ll “order for the table” but secretly want to keep. 🧄
Atmosphere
Five Points Pizza leans into that casual East Nashville energy—a comfortable dining room with just enough buzz to feel lively but not chaotic.
It’s the kind of place where family dinners, low-key first dates, and “I just need a slice and a beer” nights all feel right at home.
Full-service tables, counter-service for quick grabs, and a friendly, hip vibe that feels fun without tipping into try-hard territory keep it approachable for everyone.
Parking might make you work a little—street spots and a paid lot across the way—but if you’re grabbing takeout, that hot box of pizza more than makes up for a short walk. 🚶♂️
Bottom Line
Go to Five Points Pizza for crispy, foldable New York-style pies, creative specialty options, and garlic knots you’ll think about for days.
Between the habanero cream, that dialed-in crust, and a killer happy hour, it’s absolutely worth making this your weekly pizza pilgrimage. 🍕✨
Address:
Five Points Pizza
1012 Woodland St, Nashville, TN 37206
📞 (615) 915-4174
🕔 Mon–Thu & Sun: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM | Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM