When you think of pizza spots that can make even the toughest critics smile, Good Pie knows how to deliver the goods.
This downtown Las Vegas pizzeria has been making hearts skip a beat since opening its doors in 2018.
Owner Vincent Rotolo brought his Brooklyn expertise to the desert, and locals haven’t stopped raving about it since. 🍕
How Good Pie won local’s hearts
Good Pie didn’t just show up and hope for the best – this place earned its stripes through pure pizza passion.
When Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy dropped by for his famous one-bite review, he basically crowned them the unofficial pizza kings of Las Vegas.
But it wasn’t just one celebrity endorsement that put them on the map. Vincent Rotolo came to Vegas with serious credentials, having started his pizza journey at the legendary John’s of Bleecker Street in 1986.
The man brought authentic Brooklyn-style techniques to a city hungry for real pizza.
Their secret weapon? The grandma wall. No kidding – they literally dedicated an entire wall to photos of customers’ grandmothers, creating an emotional connection that goes way beyond just serving food.
One customer even broke down in tears when she spotted her late grandmother’s photo on display. Vincent didn’t just open a restaurant; he created a community gathering place that honors pizza traditions while serving up seriously impressive pies.
The restaurant officially earned October 13th as “Good Pie Day” in Nevada, showing just how deeply they’ve embedded themselves in local culture.
Food Highlights
- Johnny Be Good: This Brooklyn-style masterpiece features caramelized onions, mushrooms, Italian sausage, fresh garlic, and basil that creates the perfect harmony of sweet and savory flavors on a crispy thin crust
- Buffalo Chicken Grandma: A thick grandma-style crust topped with spicy buffalo chicken, ranch drizzle, and Mike’s hot honey that delivers the perfect balance of heat and cooling creaminess
- Triple Pep Detroit Style: Fair warning – this beast contains the maximum amount of pepperoni legally allowed in Nevada, featuring cupped and charred pepperoni on Detroit-style crust with extra cheese
- Sicilian Pepperoni: Traditional thick Sicilian crust loaded with premium pepperoni, fresh herbs, and that signature crispy-bottom-chewy-middle texture that makes every bite satisfying
- Upside Down Grandma with Vodka Sauce: Their signature grandma crust gets flipped with extra cheese on the bottom and creamy vodka sauce on top, creating a unique twist on classic New York style
- Fried Pizza with Burrata: First fried then baked, this creative masterpiece gets finished with creamy burrata cheese, fresh basil, and grated Parmesan for an unforgettable texture experience
Atmosphere
Good Pie radiates that authentic neighborhood pizzeria vibe that feels like stepping into a Brooklyn corner joint.
Good Pie features classic checkered floors, vintage Italian-American decor, and those leather booths that practically beg you to settle in for the long haul.
Sports play on multiple screens, creating that perfect casual dining environment where you can catch the game while demolishing a slice.
The open kitchen lets you watch the pizza makers work their magic, and the full bar serves up craft cocktails alongside local brews.
Bottom Line
- Authentic Brooklyn expertise meets Las Vegas hospitality in the best possible way
- Award-winning pizzas that have earned recognition from food critics and locals alike
- Multiple crust styles available, from thin Brooklyn rounds to thick grandma squares and Detroit-style pans
- Emotional connection through the grandma wall creates a dining experience that goes beyond just eating
- Convenient downtown location in the Arts District makes it perfect for exploring Vegas beyond the Strip
- Full bar and happy hour specials make it ideal for both quick bites and longer hangout sessions
Address: 1212 S Main Street, Las Vegas, NV 89104
📞 (702) 844-2700
🕔 Open Mon-Thu & Sun 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Fri-Sat 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM