Cincinnati’s historic Over-the-Rhine neighborhood gained a burger destination when this nostalgic diner opened at 1106 Race St in September 2021.
Milkman transforms the old Revolution Rotisserie location into a completely new space where smash burgers meet boozy shakes.
The concept came to owner Nick Pesola in a flash—burgers, boozy milkshakes, speedy service—and the name Milkman was born.
What Makes Milkman Special
The special sauce is pure magic—does the pep come from cream of tartar, nobody knows, but it elevates every burger to another level.
The mayo tastes like spring with its bright blend that marries diverse ingredients like the spice and fat in their Spicy Burger.
Smash-style burgers get the crispy edges and cheese-meat fusion that makes this technique so addictive.
The Story Behind Milkman
The space underwent a complete gut renovation, transforming from Revolution Rotisserie into something completely unrecognizable.
Modern design meets vintage Cincinnati nostalgia with old photos, Coca-Cola items, and a Pillsbury Doughboy figurine creating conversation starters.
The playlist updates weekly mixing Harry Styles and Billie Eilish with Elvis classics, capturing that ’50s diner feel for today’s crowd.
Food Highlights
- Double Deluxe – Two burger patties with American cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, grilled onions, dill pickles, and that legendary special sauce.🍔
- Spicy Burger – Heat seekers’ choice featuring jalapeño cream cheese creating creamy heat in every bite.🍔
- Chili Burger – Smothered in Cincinnati-style chili with all the fixings for local flavor.🍔
- Fried Chicken Sandwiches – Crispy chicken served multiple ways showcasing versatility beyond burgers.🍗
- Cookies and Irish Cream Shake – Soft-serve ice cream blended with vodka, Bailey’s, and Oreos topped with whipped cream.🍦
- Tofu Nuggets – Breaded and deep-fried tofu blocks with crisp savory breading contrasting fluffy bean curd.🥡
The Atmosphere at Milkman
The mix of new and old-school creates a cheeky, fun atmosphere where families and date nights both feel perfectly at home.
Order-at-the-counter service keeps things speedy, offering a quick alternative to OTR restaurants with long wait times.
The location just south of Washington Park makes it perfect for grabbing a burger after exploring the neighborhood.
Bottom Line
This is what happens when simple diner favorites get the elevated treatment from chefs who actually care about ingredients.
The boozy milkshakes alone make this worth the visit—they’re everything your inner child needs to kick off the weekend.
When locals and tourists alike rave about the balance of quality and speed, you know Over-the-Rhine has another keeper on its hands.
Address: 1106 Race St Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 381-0009
Hours: Sun-Thu: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM | Fri-Sat: 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM