Bay34th St Pizzeria feels like the kind of neighborhood discovery that quickly becomes part of a Dallas local’s regular dinner rotation.
With New York-style slices, scratch-made dough, generous toppings, and a menu that reaches well beyond pizza, this Midway Road favorite gives hungry guests plenty of reasons to return.
The result is a welcoming pizza spot where a quick slice can turn into a full meal, a family tradition, or a carefully guarded recommendation. 🍕✨
How Bay34th St Pizzeria won local heart
Bay34th St Pizzeria began winning over Dallas diners by offering something familiar yet difficult to replicate: New York-style pizza served by the slice or as a whole pie.
That flexible format makes the restaurant convenient for nearly every kind of visit, from a fast weekday lunch to a relaxed dinner with family and friends.
Its scratch-made dough gives the menu a homemade foundation, since the dough is prepared daily instead of arriving as a ready-made product.
The restaurant also connects its identity to New York through its name, which reflects an address connected to one of the owners’ upbringing.
That personal history gives the pizzeria more character than a generic neighborhood pizza counter, while the casual service keeps the experience comfortable and approachable.
Customer reviews frequently praise the crust, generous toppings, friendly staff, reasonable prices, and the convenience of ordering either a single slice or a full pizza.
For diners searching for a New York-style experience outside New York, Bay34th has earned attention as one of the closer local options available in the Dallas area.
Several guests describe the restaurant as family-run, welcoming, and suitable for both quick meals and relaxed dine-in visits.
The friendly service matters just as much as the food, especially for regulars who want to feel recognized rather than rushed through an ordinary transaction.
Bay34th also gives customers more reasons to return by serving calzones, pasta, salads, stromboli, sandwiches, stuffed pies, appetizers, and desserts alongside its pizza selection.
That broad menu makes it easier for groups with different appetites to agree on one restaurant, even when one person wants a slice and another is craving pasta or a calzone.
The restaurant’s combination of generous portions, approachable prices, New York-inspired food, and personal hospitality explains how a small pizzeria became a dependable local favorite. ❤️
Food Highlights
-
Brooklyn Stuffed Pizza: This hearty specialty pie is layered with beef sausage, beef pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sauce, and mozzarella, making it a filling choice for groups who want something more substantial than a standard slice. 🍕
-
Spinach, Ricotta, and Mozzarella Pizza: Spinach, fresh tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, seasoned ricotta, and mozzarella create a flavorful combination for diners who prefer a vegetable-focused specialty pie with plenty of richness and texture. 🌿
-
Vegetarian Pizza: Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, spinach, sauce, and mozzarella give this pizza a colorful mixture of savory toppings that customer reviews praise for its balanced flavor and satisfying crust. 🫑
-
Stromboli Rolls: Bay34th offers stromboli filled with combinations of meats, vegetables, cheese, mushrooms, olives, and onions, making these rolls a convenient choice for anyone who enjoys pizza flavors in a folded format. 🥖
-
Calzones: Served with marinara, the calzones feature seasoned ricotta and mozzarella along with options that include meat, chicken, broccoli, and vegetables, giving diners a hearty alternative to an open-faced pizza. 🧀
-
Cannoli: The homemade cannoli provides a sweet finish after a savory meal, and customer feedback describes it as a generous dessert with plenty of powdered sugar for traditional Italian pastry fans. 🍰
Atmosphere
Bay34th St Pizzeria has a relaxed, casual atmosphere that works for quick lunches, family dinners, takeout orders, and easy catch-ups with friends.
The casual setting and welcoming staff create the comfortable feeling of a neighborhood restaurant where guests can enjoy generous food without unnecessary formality. 😊
Bottom Line
Visit Bay34th for scratch-made dough, New York-style slices, generous specialty pies, broad Italian favorites, and friendly service.
It is a reliable Dallas stop for satisfying portions, relaxed meals, and pizza that encourages first-time guests to return. 🍕❤️
Address: 13605 Midway Rd Ste 170 Dallas, TX 75244
📞 (214) 774-9469
🕔 Open Mon–Sun, 10 AM–9 PM