Looking for old-school New York pizza in the middle of Hialeah that locals swear is “dummy good”? 🍕
This family-owned spot has quietly been turning out huge, foldable slices and Italian comfort classics since 1994, drawing everyone from neighborhood regulars to pizza obsessives on the hunt for the next great pie. ✨
How This Tiny Hialeah Pizzeria Became a Slice‑Obsessed Cult Favorite
What started as a humble, family-run operation back in 1994 has evolved into a word-of-mouth legend for NY-style pizza in Hialeah, thanks to its focus on quality ingredients and consistency over trends.
Generations of locals now treat Salvatore Pizza Pasta & Subs as the spot for crispy yet chewy pies, saucy baked pastas, and overflowing subs that feel like a home-cooked Italian feast in a strip-mall setting. 💥
The pizzeria’s own story highlights its family ownership and commitment to NY-style pizza and Italian dishes, mirroring the classic traits of New York–style pizza with its thin, foldable crust and cheesy goodness.
Add in glowing write-ups from happy customers plus ordering options through platforms such as SliceLife, and you get the kind of low-key neighborhood joint that quietly earns major credibility one slice at a time. 🙌
Food Highlights
-
Cheese Pizza: Classic New York–style pie with a thin, crisp base and just enough chew, built on mozzarella and tomato sauce as shown on their official menu, making it a go-to order for purists who want to taste the foundation of the kitchen. 🍕
-
Meat Lovers Pizza: A hearty specialty pie stacked with meaty toppings like pepperoni and sausage from their listed options, echoing the loaded combinations you can build through online ordering platforms, and loved by guests who want a fully loaded, shareable pie that still keeps that NY-style character.
-
Veggie Pizza: A colorful option featuring toppings such as mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes—all ingredients called out among their pizza toppings—making it a must-try for anyone who likes a lighter slice that still delivers serious flavor and texture in every bite. 🥦
-
White Pizza: A sauce-free favorite built from the cheese-forward side of the menu, leaning on mozzarella, ricotta, and garlic that fans associate with traditional white pies, ideal for diners who crave a richer, creamier option that swaps tomato tang for indulgent, melty comfort.
-
Calzone: Their calzone is stuffed with mozzarella, ricotta, and parmesan, then baked to a golden brown and served with marinara, reflected in the calzone and stromboli section on third-party menus, making it a must-order for cheese lovers who want all the goodness of pizza in a folded, handheld package.
-
Garlic Rolls: Often paired with pastas and highlighted on Italian menus across town, these garlic rolls are served warm with buttery garlic and plenty of flavor, becoming a soft, tear-apart side that guests love to dunk in sauce, turning them into a table favorite before the main plates even land. 🥖
-
Baked Lasagna: A comforting classic made with pasta, prime-choice ground beef, ricotta, homemade tomato sauce, and mozzarella, and channeling the feel of traditional Italian family dinners for guests who want something hearty, meaty, and deeply satisfying.
-
Classic Ricotta Stuffed Shells: Featuring a three-cheese ricotta filling and marinara sauce similar to the stuffed pasta options on their menu, these shells are ideal for guests who crave rich, cheesy bites without going for a heavy meat dish, rounding out a table spread with a touch of old-school Italian charm.
Atmosphere
The vibe at Salvatore Pizza Pasta & Subs is simple, cozy, and unpretentious, exactly what you’d hope for from a long-running neighborhood pizzeria spotlighted on local maps and guides.
It’s the kind of spot where families, workers, and regulars drop in for big plates of pasta, hot pies, and easy conversation after finding it through sites like Slice’s Hialeah listings.
The room feels casual and welcoming, more about comfort and familiarity than flashy décor, echoing the reviews that praise its great service and delicious food.
It’s a relaxed place where you can kick back, share a pie, and feel like you’re part of the local scene. 😌🍽️
Bottom Line
Expect NY-style pizza done right, hearty Italian classics, and garlic rolls that disappear fast.
Family ownership, a cozy neighborhood vibe, easy access through online ordering sites, and affordable, craveable comfort food make this Hialeah spot a must-visit for pizza lovers exploring South Florida. 🍕
Address:
1550 W 84th St Suite #1, Hialeah, FL 33014
📞 +1 (305) 821-7016
🕔 Open daily, Mon–Thu: 10 AM–9 PM – Fri–Sat: 10 AM–11 PM – Sun: 12 PM–9 PM