Hidden away on busy Massachusetts Avenue, this intimate Italian gem proves that the most magical dining experiences often come from the most unexpected places.
Rosemary & Olive transforms a cozy former meatball spot into a romantic escape where handmade pasta meets old-world charm in the heart of Indianapolis. 🍝✨
How Rosemary & Olive won local’s hearts
This small hole-in-the-wall spot became a local sensation through the combined expertise of three Indianapolis restaurant legends.
George Stergiopoulos of Greek Islands, Elif Ozdemir of Giorgio’s Pizza, and restaurateur Gino Pizzi joined forces to create what Indianapolis Monthly calls the “dining scene’s answer to The Avengers.”
Their perfectionist approach meant opening slowly and deliberately in May 2024, expanding the pasta-leaning menu gradually to ensure every dish met their exacting standards.
The restaurant won hearts by focusing on authentic Italian traditions while maintaining the warm, approachable service Indianapolis diners love.
Reviewers consistently praise not just the “fabulous” rigatoni bolognese and “outstanding” experience, but the friendly bar staff who provide excellent recommendations for both food and drinks.
This combination of Giorgio’s friendly vibe, Greek Islands’ efficient service, and Pizzi’s attention to every detail created an irresistible formula that quickly established them as a welcome addition to the Mass Ave family. 👨🍳
Food Highlights
- R & O Meatballs: Homemade meatballs with house sugo and ricotta – bringing beloved meatballs back to Mass Ave in their own signature style
- Rigatoni Bolognese: Traditional beef-pork-veal bolognese with parmigiano – consistently mentioned by diners as “fabulous” and a must-try dish
- Short Rib Ravioli: House-made ravioli stuffed with slow-roasted short ribs, mirepoix, and Romano cheese in light tomato basil sauce
- Gnocchi with Pesto: Pillowy house-made gnocchi tossed with fresh pesto, parmesan, and cream – described as rich and irresistible
- Creste Di Gallo with Shrimp: Unique rooster crest pasta with charred shrimp in spicy marinara cream sauce – perfect for soaking up the rich, spicy flavors
ALSO IN INDIANAPAOLIS: How This CUTE Mom and Pop Diner Won Hearts in Indianapolis, IN
Atmosphere
The restaurant creates a cozy, intimate and upscale environment perfect for date nights and special occasions.
Diners describe the space as having a pleasant atmosphere with excellent wait staff providing attentive service.
The crowded but charming interior maintains that authentic hole-in-the-wall feel while offering bar seating and outdoor patio options for warmer weather. The warm, inviting ambiance reflects traditional Italian hospitality with modern Indianapolis charm. 🕯️
Bottom Line
Visit for authentic Italian cuisine from seasoned restaurateurs, intimate date-night atmosphere, house-made pasta perfection, excellent wine selections, and that special hole-in-the-wall charm that makes every meal feel like a delicious secret discovery. 💕
Address: 870 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
📞 (317) 426-2529
🕔 Open Mon-Thu 5 PM–10 PM, Fri-Sat 5 PM–11 PM, Sun 5 PM–9 PM