Prince Street Pizza in Nolita has become a comfort-food landmark for hungry New Yorkers craving thick, saucy slices.
Fans rave about the crispy-edged Sicilian squares, spicy tomato sauce, and generous cheese that make each bite feel like serious pizza therapy.
Lines often curl down Prince Street, with locals and visitors patiently waiting for pepperoni-loaded squares that live up to the hype.
It’s the kind of place where one slice turns into two, and that first visit usually becomes a tradition.
How Prince Street Pizza won locals’ hearts
Prince Street Pizza won over locals with its bold, square Sicilian slices that deliver crunch, chew, and serious flavor in every corner.
The shop’s signature pepperoni, often curling into little cups, became a visual and flavor icon that people proudly share on social media and recommend to friends.
Regulars love that even a simple cheese slice tastes special, thanks to a rich sauce and careful baking that keeps the crust crisp yet tender.
The Boozy Broome vodka-sauce slice adds a creamy, tangy twist that keeps pizza lovers curious and coming back to try more combinations.
Picks like the Fancy Prince with fresh mozzarella offer a more indulgentthick SoHo Squares, loaded cheese experience without feeling heavy or complicated.
Those adventurous enough to try the Greene Machine pesto slice appreciate the mix of ricotta, olives, and herbs that turns it into a flavorful change of pace.
Over time, locals started treating the shop as a late-night comfort stop, trusting it for quality slices after nights out in SoHo and Little Italy.
Many guests mention that they return specifically for the , praising the way the edges stay crunchy while the middle stays soft.
The tiny, busy counter setup adds to the charm, making each visit feel like a quick neighborhood ritual rather than a long sit-down meal.
Word-of-mouth, photos of pepperoni cups, and a steady stream of glowing reviews turned Prince Street into a must-try pizza destination.
For New Yorkers, it’s become one of those spots where you send visiting friends to taste a real-deal slice experience in the heart of downtown.
All of this built a reputation that feels earned, not manufactured, which is why the shop has genuinely earned locals’ loyalty over the years.
Food Highlights
-
The Original Prince Pizza Slice: A round slice with marinara and grated mozzarella. Simple and balanced, it lets the sauce and dough shine. A great first order for new guests.
-
The Fancy Prince Pizza Slice: Made with tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. Creamier and richer, with a satisfying cheese pull. A familiar flavor with a more indulgent bite.
-
Boozy Broome Pizza Slice: Features vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella. Lightly tangy and creamy, it adds a fun twist to a classic slice. Comforting and flavorful.
-
Greene Machine Pizza Slice: Topped with pesto, mozzarella, ricotta, and gaeta olives. Herb-forward and savory, with layered flavors in every bite. Great for adventurous eaters.
-
Cheese Slice (Round): A classic plain cheese slice done right. Balanced sauce, melted cheese, and crust. A reliable comfort favorite.
-
SoHo Squares with Pepperoni: Thick Sicilian-style squares with crispy edges and pepperoni cups. Hearty, crunchy, and visually appealing. A crowd favorite.
-
Vodka-Based Sicilian Slices: Square slices with vodka sauce and a hint of spice. Rich, slightly spicy, and deeply satisfying. A great upgrade for bold flavor.
Atmosphere
Prince Street Pizza has a busy, grab-and-go slice-shop vibe, where lines move quickly and most people eat standing up or outside.
The interior is compact, with a small counter, limited ledges, and steady motion behind the ovens, making each visit feel energetic and casual.
Most guests treat it like a quick comfort stop, grabbing a box or a paper plate and enjoying their slice on the sidewalk or under the small covered area out front.
That simple, no-frills setting lets the pizza and street energy take center stage, which many food lovers find charming and authentic.
Bottom Line
Prince Street Pizza is ideal for anyone craving thick, flavorful Sicilian squares, creamy vodka slices, and classic cheese pies in a lively downtown setting.
Visit for the pepperoni-packed SoHo Squares, fun specialty slices, and a true slice-shop experience that feels like pure New York comfort food.
Address: 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
📞 (917) 905-0006
🕔Open Sun–Tue, 10 AM–3 AM | Wed, 10 AM–12 AM | Thu–Sat, 10 AM–5 AM