Tucked inside Wilmington’s lively Forty Acres neighborhood, Scalessa’s “My Way” Old School Italian Kitchen has been dishing out bold, homestyle Italian food since 2016. 🍝
It’s the kind of spot where the aromas alone stop you at the door — and the food makes you want to pull up a chair and stay all afternoon.
This is one of those hidden gem restaurants in Wilmington, DE that earns its reputation one honest, soulful plate at a time.
How Scalessa’s Won Wilmington’s Hearts
The restaurant was born out of a deep love for old-school, family-style Italian cooking — the kind passed down through generations, made from scratch, and served without pretension.
Owner Donnie Scalessa built this kitchen around the flavors he grew up with, and that personal commitment shows in every handmade meatball and every slow-simmered pot of Sunday gravy.
Since opening in 2016, Scalessa’s has quietly earned a devoted following in Wilmington’s tight-knit food community, with locals and visitors alike returning week after week for dishes that feel like a genuine Italian-American Sunday dinner.
“Dining at Scalessa’s is sure to make you feel like you’ve walked back into your Grandma’s kitchen for Sunday supper,” raved one enthusiastic fan.
Word of mouth did what no advertising campaign ever could — turning this family-owned Italian restaurant in Delaware into one of the most talked-about spots in the city.
Scalessa’s doesn’t chase trends or reinvent the wheel — it simply does what it has always done: cook real Italian food with real ingredients and real heart, and let the results speak for themselves.
🌟 For a neighborhood restaurant in Wilmington where every dish feels like it was made specifically for you, Scalessa’s isn’t just a dining destination — it’s a community institution.
Food Highlights
From award-winning meatballs to luscious pasta dishes loaded with fresh seafood, Scalessa’s menu is a love letter to classic Italian-American cooking. Here are the must-try dishes that keep locals coming back:
-
Grandma’s Sunday Gravy and Rigatoni 🍅: Rigatoni cooked al dente and ladled with a deeply rich, slow-simmered meat sauce made with tender chunks of pork butt and sweet Italian sausage.
-
Award-Winning Meatballs 🧆: Handmade daily from a generations-old recipe, these meatballs are made with ground beef, seasoned to perfection, and served with or without sweet ricotta.
- Porkette “Melt-In-Your-Mouth” 🥖: Slow-roasted, incredibly tender porkette served with bitter broccoli rabe and optional long hots.
- Baked Gnocchi with Four Cheeses 🧀: Housemade gnocchi tossed in a creamy Alfredo sauce and baked with blue cheese, sharp and mild provolone, and Parmigiano — Scalessa’s indulgent take on mac and cheese.
- Homemade Gnocchi Verdi 🦀: Pillowy housemade gnocchi served with sweet lump crab meat, fresh tomato, and wilted spinach in a savory sauce — a signature pasta dish in Wilmington that beautifully marries Italian tradition with Delaware’s beloved Mid-Atlantic seafood.
- Sausage, Beans, and Greens 🥬: Savory Italian sausage slow-cooked with hearty kidney beans and tender escarole — Donnie’s self-described favorite.
- Chicken Scalessa 🍗: Juicy chicken breast crowned with the same signature bubbling crab topping as the Veal Scalessa, served in a luxurious blush sauce.
- Veal Scalessa 🍽️: Tender veal topped with a bubbling, golden crab topping finished in a blush sauce.
Atmosphere
Scalessa’s has the kind of warm, lived-in energy that makes it an easy fit for almost any occasion. ☕
Guests consistently describe the space as having a “living room feel” — cozy, unpretentious, and exactly the kind of place where you instantly relax the moment you sit down.
The restaurant is small and casual, with a neighborhood spirit that reflects the Forty Acres community it calls home.
It’s equally perfect for a solo lunch, a catch-up with an old friend, or a laid-back family dinner — the kind of welcoming space that great family-owned restaurants in Delaware are known for.
Bottom Line
Scalessa’s “My Way” delivers award-winning handmade meatballs, slow-simmered Sunday gravy, and a menu full of old-school Italian soul in a warm, casual setting.
It’s the kind of authentic, family-owned gem that Wilmington’s dining scene was built on. Don’t leave without trying the Gnocchi Verdi. 🌟
Address:
1836 N Lincoln St, Wilmington, DE 19806
📞 (302) 656-1362
🕗 Open Mon–Thu 11 AM–8 PM | Fri–Sat 11 AM–9 PM | Sun Closed