Elliot’s Wood Fired Kitchen & Tap serves the Newark area and attracts visitors from Granville, Heath, and Hebron who gather for artisanal wood-fired pizzas.
This independent establishment has operated as a downtown landmark since its founding in 2017.
Founders Mike and Andre Sarap, along with partner Tom Sheehan, manage the operations, which transformed a historic site into a primary dining destination.
The site serves as a primary example of adaptive reuse and culinary craftsmanship within the local food scene.
A Fixture in Newark’s Dining Scene
The operational history of the business is rooted in its 16 West Main Street location, occupying the historic footprint of the former Sparta Restaurant.
Situated directly across from the Licking County Courthouse, the venue benefits from the ongoing revitalization of the downtown Newark Square.
Since its inception, the ownership group has expanded the concept to nearby Pataskala, New Albany, and Powell, while maintaining the original Newark site as the flagship anchor.
This regional brand remains a family-owned entity, with the partners also operating the Red Oak Pub within the same county.
Regional dining traditions in Central Ohio often center on the use of specialized hearth technology and locally sourced ingredients.
The kitchen utilizes a wood-fired oven imported from California, engineered to maintain the high temperatures required for a specific Neapolitan-style char.
The dough program features a lighter flour blend designed to produce a crust that is technically crisp on the edges with a chewy center.
These menu items align with a wood-fired logic that integrates contemporary toppings with traditional baking methods.
The facility functions as a community hub for the downtown district, particularly during “Final Friday” events and holiday courthouse celebrations.
Lunch hours see a mix of legal professionals and residents from Newark, while weekend shifts bring a high volume of families from Granville and Heath.
A specific behavioral pattern involves diners seeking out the “Mr. Pickle” pizza, a technical build featuring a garlic olive oil base and ranch drizzle.
This pattern has established the kitchen as a primary social engineering hub for residents seeking a specialized dining experience near the historic Licking County courthouse.
Food Highlights
-
The Mr. Pickle pizza is a technical study in flavor contrast featuring a garlic olive oil base, mozzarella, and sliced pickles.
-
Mamma Dre is a high-density protein build named after co-owner Andre Sarap, incorporating pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon.
-
Bavarian Pretzels are jumbo-sized, sprinkled with parmesan, and served with a side of house beer cheese.
-
The Margherita utilizes fresh mozzarella and a garlic olive oil drizzle finished with fresh basil.
-
Elliot’s Meatball Sub features beef and pork meatballs slow-cooked in marinara and served on a toasted sub bun.
-
Cheese Curds are breaded Wisconsin cheddar bites fried and sprinkled with parmesan cheese.
-
Street Tacos are offered in multiple varieties, including braised chicken and seasoned shrimp with sriracha mayo.
-
Smash Burgers are prepared with American cheese and garlic aioli on a toasted brioche bun.
Atmosphere
The layout features a combination of industrial and rustic elements, with exposed brick walls and high-top tables surrounding a central bar area.
The wood-fired oven acts as a focal point for guest behavior, providing a direct view of the high-heat cooking process from the dining floor.
Peak times occur during the evening hours when the customer flow includes visitors attending performances at the nearby Midland Theatre.
The environment remains focused on a “neighborhood taproom” identity, blending the scent of burning wood with a high-energy social setting.
Bottomline
This establishment represents a nine-year commitment to the economic and culinary growth of Central Ohio. It caters primarily to regional residents and residents who value independent ownership and artisanal preparation styles. Independent restaurants like this play a critical role in defining the social character and historic continuity of the local landscape.
📍: 16 W Main St, Newark, OH 43055
📞: (740) 670-8510
🕒: SUN-THU 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM; FRI-SAT 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM