2 Brother’s Pizza knows how to win hearts with homemade dough, wood-fired crusts, and an owner who actually cares about his customers. 🍕
Since taking over the former First Class Pizza spot in July 2024, brothers Bill and Anthony have transformed a dead restaurant into the neighborhood’s hottest gathering place.
Their secret recipe pizza sauce made from vine tomatoes and fresh herbs, combined with their blend of three cheeses, creates pizzas that locals describe as “better than First Class was ten years ago.”
How 2 Brothers won local’s hearts
2 Brother’s Pizza didn’t just open – they rescued a beloved community spot from obscurity.
When the previous owners at First Class Pizza let quality slide and the restaurant became “a dead shop,” longtime customers thought they’d lost their favorite neighborhood pizza place forever.
But when Bill and Anthony took over in July 2024, they made a bold commitment: they wouldn’t cut corners like the previous owners did.
The brothers completely rebranded the space because they knew a fresh start was necessary to win back trust.
The magic happened through genuine hospitality and obsessive attention to quality.
Bill personally greets customers, sits down to chat about life and business, and even bought kids surprise Oreo dessert pizzas just because he could.
When one family brought 25 people for a last-minute birthday party, the staff welcomed them with open arms and made the celebration stress-free.
Their Roto Flex oven cranks out 28 pizzas at once, but they still take time to ensure each crust gets that perfect wood-fired crispiness that customers from New York actually approve of.
Food Highlights
- Rockin’ Riverside: This signature pizza packs so much flavor that customers call it “a party in my mouth” – loaded with premium toppings and that famous three-cheese blend that creates the perfect cheese pull every single time
- Meat Lovers: Features pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, ham, and bacon piled high on their crispy crust – reviewers consistently say it’s “heavy” in the best possible way, proving they don’t skimp on the good stuff
- Great White: A cheese lover’s dream combining pizza cheese with feta, creating a rich and tangy flavor profile that keeps customers coming back for more creamy goodness
- The Works: Pizza sauce, pizza cheese, pepperoni, onions, mushrooms, sausage, hamburger, ham, black olives, and garlic – basically everything you could want on a pizza without having to make tough decisions
- Bill’s Pepperoni: Named after one of the owners, this specialty pizza features their signature ground pepperoni that delivers more flavor per bite than traditional sliced pepperoni
Atmosphere
2 Brother’s Pizza creates that perfect neighborhood hangout vibe where families feel as welcome as sports fans catching the game. 📺
The newly renovated space features multiple big-screen TVs, clean seating both inside and on the outdoor patio, and a cozy dining room perfect for birthday parties or date nights.
Kids get chalkboards to draw on while parents enjoy ice-cold draft beer for just $5. The music stays at the perfect volume for conversation, and the open kitchen lets you smell those wood-fired pizzas baking while you wait.
The decor strikes the right balance between casual and welcoming – no pretentious nonsense, just a comfortable place where the owners actually know your name.
Bottom Line
- Authentic wood-fired pizza that rivals New York quality at California prices
- Family-owned hospitality where the brothers personally ensure every customer feels like a regular
- Incredible value with $5 draft beers, daily specials, and generous portions that actually fill you up
- Perfect for groups – they’ll accommodate last-minute parties and make your celebration memorable
- Fresh ingredients and homemade everything, from the dough to the pizza sauce made with vine tomatoes 🍅
Address: 4290 Riverwalk Pkwy, Ste 310 Riverside, CA 92505
📞 (951) 354-7900
🕔 Sun-Thu 11 AM–9 PM, Fri-Sat 11 AM–10 PM