Why Locals Adore Bleecker Street Pizza for Authentic Thin Crust in New York, NY

Award-winning slices, bold flavor, and a loyal following make this West Village favorite a must-visit for real New York pizza lovers.

Photos for Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Name
Bleecker Street Pizza
Address
69 7th Ave S New York, NY 10014
Hours
Sun-Thu 11:30AM-11PM, Fri-Sat 11:30AM-12AM

Bleecker Street Pizza ignites New Yorkers’ pizza passion with its legendary thin crust.

This West Village icon has drawn devoted crowds since 2004, celebrated for slices that strike the perfect balance between crispy, chewy, and boldly flavorful.

From late-night cravings to daytime comfort eats, it’s a spot locals instinctively recommend when real New York pizza is the mission.

Locals and visitors alike rave about pies that deliver pure NY magic every single time.

nonna maria (left) and chipotle chicken (right) slices at Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Jeanne

How Bleecker Street Pizza won locals’ hearts

Bleecker Street Pizza earned Greenwich Village devotion by perfecting the classic New York slice night after night.

Freshly made dough, vibrant sauce, and premium toppings hooked fans from day one in 2004.

The Nona Maria Pie soon exploded in popularity, blending a family-recipe marinara with fresh mozzarella, parmesan, and basil for unbeatable balance.

Food Network awards followed three years in a row, cementing its reputation as a thin-crust king.

House Special Pizza at Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Justin

The New York Times praised its excellence, while USA Today ranked it among the nation’s Top 10 pizzerias.

WPIX11 crowned it #BestPizza, sparking lines that stretch from late-night partiers to Sunday family crowds.

Generous portions at wallet-friendly prices sealed the deal, turning first-time bites into lifelong loyalty.

No gimmicks—just consistent, craveable pies that make every visit feel like coming home.

Word-of-mouth spread through the Village like wildfire as locals shared tales of that signature crispy-edged perfection.

Today, it remains the go-to for authentic flavor in a city full of pretenders.

Food Highlights

Photos for Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Emily
  • Nona Maria Pie: Family-recipe thin crust topped with fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara, parmesan, and basil—a must-try for its harmony and award-winning appeal.

  • Sicilian Pie: Thick, square slices loaded with sauce and cheese, perfect for hearty appetites craving extra crunch and chew.

  • Grandma Pie: Crispy thin square with fresh toppings and ideal char, loved for its old-school simplicity.

  • Gluten-Free Pizza: Classic pizza flavor without the gluten, ideal for inclusive meals with no sacrifice.

  • Cauliflower Pizza: Low-carb base with traditional toppings, praised by keto fans for surprising crispiness.

  • Pepperoni Slice: Hot, cheesy classic with cup-and-char pepperoni—the ultimate late-night indulgence.

Photos for Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Lauren

Atmosphere

This cozy West Village nook buzzes with welcoming energy.

Staff greet everyone with genuine smiles amid the irresistible aroma of baking pies.

Tight seating creates a lively neighborhood feel, perfect for quick bites or group feasts.

Casual and unpretentious, it captures the true soul of NYC pizza.

Photos for Bleecker Street Pizza in New York, NY
Hector

Bottom Line

Come for the award-winning pies, vibrant vibes, and unbeatable value—stay for the addictive New York chew.

Group-friendly bliss awaits.

Address: 69 7th Ave S New York, NY 10014

📞 (212) 924-4466

🕔 Sun-Thu 11:30AM-11PM, Fri-Sat 11:30AM-12AM