This family-owned pizzeria has been keeping Elk Grove residents well-fed since 1992, and the secret’s out.
Fat Mike’s doesn’t mess around when it comes to toppings—they pile them on with literal “handfuls” instead of counting every mushroom and olive like some corporate chain. 🍕
With 26 specialty pizzas on the menu and gluten-free options available, this spot has earned its reputation as one of the best pizza joints in Elk Grove.
The diner-esque interior welcomes families who want quality food without the fancy price tag.
The Kitchen Sink Special: Mike’s Top Ten Combination
When a pizza’s named after the owner and loaded with ten ingredients, you know it means business.
Mike’s Top Ten Combination throws down pepperoni, onions, green bell peppers, mushrooms, ham, salami, sausage, olives, beef, and extra cheese onto one glorious pie.
According to Yelp reviewers, this is the go-to flavor that keeps people coming back. One customer tried the Barbecue Chicken, Pesto Italian, and pepperoni varieties but declared Mike’s Top Ten their absolute favorite.
With all those fresh toppings piled high, you’re getting a different flavor combination in every bite. This pizza doesn’t hold back—it’s the kind of meal that requires napkins and zero shame.
The Cowboy Rides Into Town
Ranch sauce lovers, this one’s calling your name.
The Cowboy pizza swaps traditional red sauce for creamy ranch, then loads up with pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, olives, onions, and pepperoncini for that perfect tangy kick. 😋
With 9 reviews specifically praising this flavor on Yelp, it’s clearly a crowd favorite. One 20-year customer called it “a white sauce pizza with an amazing taste and crunch.”
The pepperoncini add just enough heat to cut through the richness of the ranch and cheese, while the sausage and pepperoni bring that savory punch. If you’ve never tried ranch as a pizza sauce, this is your gateway drug.
Garlic Sticks That Deserve Their Own Fan Club
These aren’t your average breadsticks thrown in as an afterthought. The garlic sticks with cheese at Fat Mike’s come 12 to an order for $14.99, and they’re worth every penny.
They arrive nice and hot with very gooey cheese and come with sides of ranch and marinara for dipping. Pro tip: you can also get them with bacon for an extra dollar if you’re feeling dangerous.
Multiple Yelp reviewers have called these out specifically, with one stating they’re “highly recommend” and noting they’re “very soft and quite flavorful with the garlic seasoning.”
Atmosphere
Walking into Fat Mike’s feels like stepping back into a classic 90s neighborhood pizzeria.
The diner-like setting provides plenty of seating for families, and there’s even a small arcade area in the back with games to keep kids entertained. 🎮
The staff stays friendly and personable, making it feel like a true local family business. Whether you’re dining in, grabbing takeout, or getting delivery, the service remains consistently excellent.
This is the kind of place where regulars have been coming for 20 years, and new customers immediately understand why.
Bottom Line
-
Serving Elk Grove since 1992 with made-to-order pizzas and fresh ingredients
-
Generous “handfuls” of toppings instead of corporate portion control nonsense
-
26 specialty pizza options including gluten-free crusts and low-carb pizza bowls
-
Family-friendly atmosphere with arcade games and welcoming staff
-
Active community supporter sponsoring local youth sports teams for decades
Address: 8970 Grant Line Rd, Elk Grove, CA 95624
📞 (916) 686-8543
🕔 Sun: 11 AM–9 PM, Mon: 3 PM–9 PM, Tue-Thu: 11 AM–9 PM, Fri: 11 AM–10 PM, Sat: 11 AM–10 PM