Don’t Sleep on These Hidden Gem Restaurants in New Haven, CT!

By Jeremy Schwegmann
BlogConnecticutFoodHidden Gem RestaurantsRestaurants

Hey New Haven! Have you tried these two hidden gems?

Next Door is redefining the pizzeria experience in New Haven, CT, with its broad menu that goes beyond classic pizza offerings. This spot has garnered acclaim for its hearty, flavorsome dishes and a warm, welcoming vibe. Meanwhile, Sherkaan Indian Street Food presents a fusion of traditional Indian street fare with a contemporary flair. Situated near Yale University, this restaurant is celebrated for its inventive menu and vibrant ambiance.

Next Door

Next Door is a truly delightful pizzeria, offering much more than just pizza. It stands out for its generous, tasty offerings and a friendly, accommodating atmosphere. Regulars praise its consistency and personalized touches, like a heart drawn next to a name on a pizza box, showcasing its commitment to customer delight.

White clam pizza! Simon W.

Food Highlights:

  • Pizza: Generous toppings, with options like pepperoni and New Haven-style thin crust.
  • Buffalo Cauliflower Bites: A savory treat.
  • Green Truck Salad: Fresh and generously portioned.
  • Strawberry Shortcake: Moist cake with a delicious crust, made in-house.
  • Desserts: A variety of homemade options, including ice cream.

Atmosphere:

Next Door provides a welcoming and relaxed environment. The staff’s kindness and efficiency enhance the dining experience. Its decor creates a chill vibe, making it an ideal spot for hosting events.

Bottom Line: Next Door is a must-visit for its delightful array of pizzas and homemade desserts. With its reasonable prices, great staff, and convenient location, it’s perfect for a casual meal or a special event. The restaurant’s charm lies in its ability to create a memorable dining experience, making it a favorite in the local community.

Location: 175 Humphrey St New Haven, CT 06511

See Also

Sherkaan Indian Street Food

Sherkaan Indian Street Food in New Haven, CT, offers a unique dining experience that artfully blends traditional Indian street food with a modern twist. Located close to Yale University, this restaurant is a must-visit for its creative menu and lively atmosphere.

Food Highlights:

  • Dahi Puri: A recommended appetizer, praised for its taste.
  • Vada Pav Sliders: A unique dish, described as irresistible.
  • Goat Curry: Rich and flavorful, with a hint of spice.
  • Butter Chicken with Cheese Naan: A creamy and delicious combination.
  • Biryani: Noted for its generous portion and exquisite taste.
  • Hakka Noodles and Chilli Chicken: A delightful fusion of Indian and Chinese flavors.
  • Drinks: The Mumbai Manhattan and Nimbu Pani spiked with tequila stand out for their exceptional presentation.

Atmosphere:

The decor of Sherkaan Indian Street Food captures the essence of urban India without being overly gimmicky. The restaurant offers a welcoming and festive vibe, enhanced by Indian music.

Rose Q.

The presence of diverse clientele, including college students, tourists, and locals, adds to the lively and inclusive ambiance. Even in cooler temperatures, the outdoor patio provides a comfortable dining experience.

Bottom Line: Sherkaan Indian Street Food is a gem in New Haven’s dining scene, offering an array of tantalizing dishes that cater to both Indian food aficionados and those new to the cuisine. The combination of delightful flavors, a vibrant atmosphere, and attentive service makes it an unmissable destination.

Location: 65 Broadway New Haven, CT 06511