New Jersey’s most beloved mom-and-pop diner has been feeding generations of hungry locals since 1942 — and it just keeps getting better. 🍳
From a humble roadside grill on Passaic Avenue to a $10 million landmark that Time Out magazine once dubbed the best diner in America, Tops Diner in East Newark, New Jersey, is the kind of place that makes you believe in the magic of family-owned restaurants.
It’s a rare treasure in today’s dining world: a multigenerational, family-owned diner that has somehow managed to honor its roots while boldly evolving with the times. 🏆
How Tops Diner won East Newark’s hearts
The story of Tops Diner begins long before its current form — all the way back to 1938, when a man named Jess P. Persson operated Tops Grill at the very same location on Passaic Avenue where the diner proudly stands today.
George Golemis purchased Tops in 1972, and what followed was decades of expansion, remodeling, and a fierce, unwavering commitment to quality that East Newark locals came to depend on like their morning coffee. ☕
George’s three sons — Van, Jimmy, and John — grew up quite literally inside these walls, sweeping floors and washing dishes before they were old enough to drive.
Van, the eldest, started working at the family diner at just twelve years old, developing the administrative instincts and work ethic that would later keep the operation running like clockwork.
Jimmy, the storyteller of the family, traveled the world — from local markets to international destinations — bringing back flavors and ideas that quietly elevated the menu into something extraordinary. 🌍
John, the youngest and self-described wild card, enrolled at the New York Restaurant School and returned armed with both professional training and a lifelong passion for pushing the boundaries of classic diner fare.
Together, the Golemis brothers took over operations and launched an ambitious four-year, $10 million renovation that demolished the old building and erected an entirely new, world-class facility in its place.
Lines of customers still go out the door, just like they did in the old days — a testament to the kind of deeply rooted local loyalty that no amount of marketing can manufacture.
Each year, Tops regularly receives “best diner” awards from newspapers, magazines, travel guides, and online publications, cementing its reputation as more than just a local gem — it’s a New Jersey institution. 🥇
On special occasions, guests can even grab a bottle of bubbly from a Champagne vending machine right on the premises — because at Tops, every meal is worth celebrating. 🥂
Food Highlights
-
George’s Special: Farm fresh eggs any style, hash browns, applewood smoked bacon, pork sausage links, and two scratch-made buttermilk pancakes — the quintessential all-in-one breakfast.
- Disco Fries: A New Jersey diner classic — crispy French fries piled high with melted mozzarella and house-made 1942 brown gravy.
- Nutella French Toast: Thick brioche dipped in vanilla bourbon custard batter, topped with Nutella, fresh banana, strawberry, and whipped cream.
-
Lobster Mac: The showstopper. Five-cheese sauce loaded with buttered Maine knuckle and claw lobster meat, cognac, shallot, tomato, chives, and garlic crumbs.
-
Famous Meatloaf: A secret-recipe meatloaf finished with demi-glaze sauce, mushrooms, Yukon gold mashed potatoes, and mixed veggies.
- Shrimp & Grits: Sautéed shrimp with Cajun seasoning over cheddar grits with baby spinach, peppers, onions, and smoked paprika butter. 🍤
- Short Rib Grilled Cheese: Slow-cooked short ribs, fontina, cheddar, and Swiss on caramelized onion sourdough. 🧀
- Corned Beef Hash & Eggs: Made fresh every day with onions and potatoes, served with farm-fresh eggs any style, hash browns, and two buttermilk pancakes.
- Firecracker Shrimp: Crispy fried shrimp tossed in a bold firecracker sauce, served over a bed of jasmine rice with pickled vegetables and scallions.
-
Southern Fried Chicken: Half chicken in a house-seasoned batter, pressure fried and plated with Yukon gold mashed potato, chicken gravy, hot honey, and fresh corn. 🍗
Atmosphere
Step inside Tops Diner and you’ll feel it immediately — this is not your average greasy spoon.
The 15,000-square-foot interior boasts a multi-toned terrazzo floor described as “an absolute work of art,” centered around an 18-stool counter adorned with black marble and a full cocktail bar. 🎶
Customers and food writers alike describe the vibe as “a bougie diner experience” — modern and upscale, complete with a resident DJ spinning on Friday through Sunday evenings.
Bottom Line
Tops Diner is a once-in-a-generation dining experience — a family-owned New Jersey legend with over 80 years of history, award-winning food, a stunning interior, DJ nights, and heart-and-soul hospitality that no chain restaurant could ever replicate. 🌟
Address:
500 Passaic Ave, East Newark, NJ 07029
🕔 Open Sun–Sat, 8 AM–11 PM