In a bustling Dallas food scene where pizza joints fight for attention, one small spot inside The Vista mall has quietly built a loyal following.
Minchello’s Pizzeria serves up authentic New York-style pies that consistently earn rave reviews, proving that sometimes the best things come from the most unexpected places.
This wood-fired pizza haven in Lewisville has captured hearts one slice at a time. 🍕
How Minchello’s won local’s hearts
Minchello’s didn’t win over Lewisville through flashy marketing or prime real estate—they did it the old-fashioned way, through consistently exceptional pizza that rivals anything you’d find in the Big Apple.
Located on the second floor of The Vista mall (formerly Vista Ridge Mall), this unassuming food court spot has earned a devoted following among locals who swear it’s “the best New York Style pizza in the Dallas area”.
What started as a mall food court experiment has transformed into a local institution. Word spread organically through satisfied customers who couldn’t believe they’d found authentic NY-style pizza in a Texas mall.
Reviews consistently praise their “consistent quality and absolutely delicious” pies, with many customers declaring it their “favorite pizza place in the area”.
The restaurant maintains a stellar 4.6-star rating across hundreds of reviews, a testament to their unwavering commitment to quality. 📊
Food Highlights
- The Meat Pizza: Loaded with pepperoni, bacon, Canadian bacon, and sausage, this carnivore’s dream comes perfectly balanced on their signature thin crust, with each meat contributing its own distinct flavor profile while the quality mozzarella holds everything together beautifully.
- Supreme Pizza: Features pepperoni, sausage, onion, bell peppers, black olives, and mushrooms creating a classic combination that showcases fresh vegetables alongside premium meats, all complemented by their perfectly seasoned tomato sauce and expertly melted cheese blend.
- The West Pizza: Topped with pepperoni, jalapeños, pineapple, garlic, and extra cheese, this unique creation delivers a sweet and spicy experience that balances tropical pineapple with the heat of fresh jalapeños while the extra cheese creates an indulgent, satisfying bite.
- Classic Cheese Pizza: Reviewers consistently rave about this simple yet perfect pie, featuring their house-made sauce and premium mozzarella on a thin crust with no flop, proving that sometimes the most basic option showcases a pizzeria’s true skill and commitment to quality ingredients.
- 18-Inch Whole Cheese Pizza: The most popular item among customers, this massive pie feeds a crowd while maintaining the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio that has made Minchello’s famous, with a crisp undercarriage that holds up beautifully despite the generous toppings. 🎯
Atmosphere
Minchello’s occupies a unique space within The Vista mall’s food court environment, creating an unexpectedly charming dining experience.
While the setting might seem unconventional for award-worthy pizza, the second-floor location offers diners “a beautiful view” of the mall’s bustling activity below.
The casual, no-frills atmosphere allows the food to be the star, while the friendly staff creates a welcoming environment that keeps customers coming back.
Despite being housed in a mall setting, reviewers consistently note that “this mall pizzeria” shouldn’t be underestimated, as it delivers an authentic New York pizza experience that rivals standalone restaurants. ✨
Bottom Line
- Authentic New York-style pizza that consistently delivers on flavor and quality
- Outstanding value with generous portions and reasonable prices
- Convenient location with easy mall parking and accessibility
- Proven track record with hundreds of positive reviews and loyal customers
- Hidden gem status that makes discovering it feel like finding a secret treasure 💎
Address: 2401 S Stemmons Fwy, Suite 2332
Lewisville, TX 75067
📞 (972) 459-5565
🕔 Mon-Sat: 11am-7pm, Sun: 12pm-6pm