Most pizza places serve basic slices, but this Nolita shop perfected Sicilian squares with pepperoni cups creating legends since 2012.
Prince Street Pizza specializes in SoHo Squares and Neapolitan pizzas using Morano family recipes based on “if you can put it on pasta you can put it on pizza.”
The casual moderate-noise atmosphere with walls covered in celebrity photos creates grab-and-go vibes where lines move fast throughout late-night service.
What Makes Prince Street Pizza Special
The restaurant uses a water filtration process replicating New York water in all locations, ensuring consistent dough texture throughout markets outside NYC.
Spicy Spring square with seasoned spicy marinara, thick crust, and thick-cut pepperoni cups earns 387 reviews as the legendary slice worth waiting for.
Open until 5 AM on weekends, this kitchen serves late-night crowds who think of these slices often throughout their lives after visiting.
The Story Behind the Squares
Prince St. Pizza opened in 2012 in New York City bringing Morano family recipes passed down for generations throughout the Nolita neighborhood.
The simple idea that pasta toppings work on pizza created innovation that built a name across New York, Miami, and California locations.
The commitment to consistency and perfect bite in every pie uses freshest ingredients with handcrafted sauces made daily from scratch throughout operations.
Manhattan’s Favorite Menu Items
Food Highlights
- Spicy Spring: Seasoned spicy marinara sauce on thick crust topped with thick-cut pepperoni cups creates the 387-review classic grandma square. The great execution makes this worth risking mouth burns from impatience, proving best pizza after nights out. 🌶️
- Pepperoni Pizza: The legendary original spicy slice with 570 reviews defines Prince Street throughout addicting pepperoni flavor that isn’t too spicy. The amazing crisp with great pepperoni makes this bomb slice the must-try for NYC visitors throughout bucket-list pizza places. 🍕
- Naughty Pie: Spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, whipped ricotta, and Zab’s hot honey at $7 creates the favorite of the day. The savory-saucy-spicy with sweetness hints proves so good people still think about it, paired perfectly with thick-cut pepperoni throughout thicker bread vessels. 🍯
- Prince St: The signature square at 298 reviews showcases the SoHo Square that made this pizzeria famous throughout Nolita. The home of the SoHo Square delivers premium quality that built a reputation across multiple cities. 🟥
- Sicilian Slice: Traditional Sicilian preparation at 180 reviews proves the foundation remains strong throughout diverse menu offerings. The thick crust squares deliver New York Sicilian-style pizza with proper execution throughout classic preparations. 🍕
- Spicy Vodka Slice: Vodka sauce with spice creates delicious flavor that pairs well with hot honey throughout creative combinations. The good flavor compensates for occasionally lukewarm temperature when lines move too fast throughout busy service. 🌶️
- Margherita Slice: Classic tomato sauce with fresh mozzarella and basil at 106 reviews delivers traditional Neapolitan flavors throughout simple preparations. The high-quality ingredients shine through proper fundamentals throughout original pizza offerings. 🍅
- Cheese Pizza: Basic cheese slice at 73 reviews provides a foundational option for those wanting straightforward New York pizza throughout classic offerings. The quality extends even to the simplest preparations throughout the complete menu. 🧀
- Crispy Pepperoni: Extra-crispy version at 67 reviews creates alternative preparation for those wanting more crunch throughout pepperoni slices. The option to request “extra crispy” proves customization available throughout fast-moving service. 🍕
- Greene Machine: Pesto-based slice creates the personal favorite for those seeking non-red sauce options throughout vegetable preparations. The 10/10 rating proves creative toppings work when executed properly throughout diverse offerings. 🌿
Atmosphere
The Nolita location sits at 27 Prince Street with limited seating including a small bench inside and two standing tables outside.
Inside, walls covered in photos of famous visitors create casual dining vibes where grab-and-go dominates throughout the small joint.
The line out the door moves relatively quickly despite crowds, proving efficient service throughout piping-hot fresh slice distribution.
Bottom Line
Visit Prince Street Pizza for Manhattan’s legendary Sicilian squares featuring Spicy Spring, Naughty Pie, and pepperoni worth the Nolita trip.
The Morano family recipes perfected since 2012 with water filtration replicating NYC water prove dedication to consistency throughout all locations.
Late-night hours until 5 AM on weekends with fast-moving lines make this the best pizza after nights out. 🌟
Address: Prince Street Pizza
27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012 (Nolita)
🕐 Mon-Tue: 10:00 AM – 3:00 AM | Wed: 10:00 AM – 12:00 AM | Thu-Sat: 10:00 AM – 5:00 AM | Sun: 10:00 AM – 3:00 AM
Multiple locations | Limited seating | Outdoor tables | Catering available | Delivery available