This Family Tavern Serves Same Pizza Recipe Since 1962 That Generations Love in Trenton, NJ

Name

Jojo's Tavern

Address

2677 Nottingham Way, Trenton, NJ 08619

Hours

Mon-Thu: 11:30 AM–11:00 PM | Fri-Sat: 11:30 AM–12:00 AM | Sun: 12:30 PM–11:00 PM

Since 1962, this family-owned neighborhood tavern has been serving generations of Trenton families, evolving from a working-class shot-and-beer joint into a beloved sports bar and full Italian restaurant. 🍕

Jojo’s Tavern was founded by Joseph and Lena Scharibone, who bravely bought the business despite knowing nothing about operating a bar—today, their grandson Joey runs the third-generation establishment.

From the famous Spicy Mustard Pie to innovative specialty combinations, every pizza honors the original recipe that has never changed in over six decades. 🏈

How Jojo’s Tavern won Trenton’s hearts

When Joseph and Lena Scharibone opened Jojo’s Tavern in 1962, Mercerville was developing as a bedroom community alongside thriving Trenton factories that needed a neighborhood watering hole.

Their grandson Joey Scharibone inherited more than just a business—he received a legacy of community connection that defines every aspect of how Jojo’s operates today.

The decision to remain completely family-owned without any managers created an operation where three generations work together, with cousin Justin Russomanno bringing culinary arts training to the kitchen.

Joey and Justin collaborate on new menu items while staying true to their basic premise: great food, moderately priced, always fresh, always cooked to order, and prepared with pride.

The pizza recipe has never changed since 1962, creating a consistency that allows customers who moved away or retired out of state to return and find the pizza exactly as they remembered it.

Their transformation from pizza and sandwich operation to full-service Italian restaurant happened gradually, with expanded kitchens accommodating hand-cut steaks, fresh seafood, house-made soups, and signature dishes.

The signature bar pies with their thin, crispy crust became legendary throughout Trenton, drawing pizza enthusiasts from across New Jersey seeking authentic thin-crust perfection.

Food Highlights

• Spicy Mustard Pie: Innovative bar pie featuring spicy mustard as a unique base—this creative specialty became so popular it earned cult-favorite status among regulars.

• Clams Casino Pizza: Fresh clams, bacon, peppers, and breadcrumb topping on a bar pie crust—this seafood-inspired creation delivers classic Italian-American flavors.

• Buffalo Chicken Pizza: Spicy buffalo sauce, tender chicken, and melted cheese topped with blue cheese drizzle.

• Pepperoni Bar Pie: Premium pepperoni covering the thin, foldable crust.

• Margherita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce on the classic bar pie crust—traditional Italian simplicity executed with the family’s six-decade expertise

• Meat Lovers Bar Pie: Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and ham on the signature thin crust—carnivores appreciate the generous portions and perfectly crispy base

• Veggie Pizza: Fresh vegetables including peppers, onions, mushrooms, and olives on the classic bar pie—vegetable lovers enjoy the quality toppings on the legendary thin crust

• White Pizza: Creamy ricotta and mozzarella blend without tomato sauce on the signature thin crust—this simple pie allows the quality of the cheese and crust to shine

Atmosphere

Step into this warm neighborhood sports tavern decorated with vintage photographs, newspaper clippings, and 13 large-screen TVs showing every professional and college game imaginable.

The comfortable seating and neutral color palette create a casual environment where three generations of families gather to celebrate, watch their favorite teams, and enjoy meals together.

This true neighborhood pub maintains the sense of community that’s kept locals returning since 1962, creating memories across multiple generations of Trenton families.

Bottom Line

Visit Jojo’s Tavern for signature bar pies using the same recipe since 1962, three generations of Scharibone family hospitality creating genuine community connections, innovative pizzas like Spicy Mustard and Clams Casino, 13 big-screen TVs making it the perfect sports bar, and thin-crust perfection that keeps customers coming back for over six decades.

Address:

2677 Nottingham Way, Trenton, NJ 08619

📞 (609) 586-2678

🕔 Mon-Thu: 11:30 AM–11:00 PM | Fri-Sat: 11:30 AM–12:00 AM | Sun: 12:30 PM–11:00 PM