On Person Street in the heart of downtown Fayetteville, NC, a little restaurant is doing something big. Circa 1800 describes its cooking as “southern boujee cuisine” — and honestly, that phrase does all the heavy lifting. 🌿✨
This locally-owned gem is serving elevated New Southern fare rooted in community, local ingredients, and a whole lot of soul, making it one of the most talked-about independent restaurants in all of North Carolina.
If you’re passing through Fayetteville and skip this place, you’ll regret it.
How Circa 1800 Won Fayetteville’s Hearts
Circa 1800 didn’t just open a restaurant — it planted a flag for what locally-owned dining in Fayetteville, NC could look like. 🏆
The owners leaned hard into their philosophy of “locally focused New Southern cuisine” — sourcing from nearby producers and crafting a menu that rotates seasonally so that every visit feels fresh and intentional.
The restaurant’s setting on Person Street in historic downtown Fayetteville adds a layer of charm that chain restaurants simply can’t replicate.
The building carries an old-world character that perfectly matches the restaurant’s name, and dining here feels like you’ve uncovered something special hiding in plain sight. 🏛️
What truly cemented Circa 1800’s place in the community, though, is the breadth and creativity of its seasonal menu.
From brunch to dinner, the kitchen swings effortlessly between inventive Southern comfort plates and more refined, sophisticated entrées.
That versatility — the ability to satisfy a lazy Sunday brunch craving and a special date-night dinner with equal finesse — is the hallmark of a truly exceptional locally-owned restaurant in North Carolina. T
he result is a dining institution that has earned its standing as one of the best restaurants in Fayetteville and a coveted Travelers’ Choice designation — remarkable for a small, intimate spot on a single downtown block. 🥂
Food Highlights 🍽️
-
Southern Egg Rolls: Crispy egg roll wrappers filled with classic Southern ingredients, served with a dipping sauce. 🥢
-
Shrimp & Grits: Sautéed shrimp in a rich parmesan-bacon sauce over creamy local stone-ground yellow grits with Vidalia onions, cheddar, and scallions — a cornerstone of the Southern boujee dining experience.
-
Brisket Nachos: House-smoked brisket piled over crispy chips with black-eyed peas, fried green tomatoes, scallion ranch, white cheddar, fried collard ribbons, and runny eggs. 🧀
-
Filet Tips: Tender, buttery filet cuts served as an entrée — a perennial favorite among diners who want steak-quality flavor in a relaxed, New Southern setting.
-
Circa Chicken Piccata: Pan-seared chicken in a bright, lemony piccata sauce — a classic Italian preparation with a Southern soul.
-
Classic Meatloaf: A deeply satisfying house meatloaf that diners have specifically traveled for — rich, hearty, and plated with care.
- Chilean Sea Bass: A refined, silky fish entrée that showcases the kitchen’s more elevated side — delicate and flaky. 🐟
-
Atlantic Beach Pie: A beloved coastal North Carolina dessert classic — tart, creamy, and finished with a salty-sweet cracker crust. 🥧
Atmosphere 🏠
Circa 1800 is intimate, intentional, and undeniably charming — a small dining room with low lighting, warm tones, and a historic downtown streetfront setting that feels like stepping into a beautifully preserved slice of Fayetteville’s past.
The space is cozy rather than cramped, with outdoor seating on Person Street that makes for a lovely evening when the Carolina weather cooperates. 🌇
The creative cocktail menu, full bar, and attentive staff round out a dining experience that feels genuinely special — the kind of place you dress up for, linger over dessert at, and leave already planning your next visit.
Bottom Line
Circa 1800 is Fayetteville’s most celebrated locally-owned restaurant for good reason — its rotating Southern menu, creative brunch, and intimate downtown setting deliver an experience that far exceeds expectations.
From the legendary egg rolls to the Atlantic Beach Pie, every bite feels like it was made with genuine love. 🌟
Address:
108 Person St, Fayetteville, NC 28301
📞 (910) 568-4725
🕔 Open Wed–Thu, 5 PM–9 PM | Fri–Sat, 5 PM–10 PM | Sun, 10 AM–2:30 PM (closed Mon–Tue)