What started as a food truck parked on I Street has grown into one of downtown Modesto’s most talked-about pizza destinations, and Sacred Slice recently made the leap from truck to storefront on 15th Street.
The move brought an expanded menu with sandwiches, beer, and wine, but the pizza that built its reputation, both New York-style slices and Detroit-style pan pies, remains exactly what put this spot on the map.
Why This Downtown Modesto Pizza Truck Built A Cult Following
Sacred Slice built its name on offering two distinct pizza styles side by side: thin, foldable New York slices and thick, focaccia-like Detroit pan pizza with a light, airy crumb.
That range gives regulars a reason to order something different every visit, whether they’re craving a classic foldable slice or a heartier, caramelized pan pie.
Longtime fans consistently point to the crust as the real differentiator, noting that whether you order New York style or Detroit style, the texture and flavor are unlike anything else available in town.
That kind of consistency helped the operation build enough of a following as a food truck to justify the recent jump into a full storefront.
For a first visit, the PRH Pizza and the Vodka Roni Pizza cover two of the dishes locals mention most, and ordering one of each in Detroit style versus New York style is a popular way to compare the two crust styles side by side.
Since slices are sold individually alongside whole pies, it’s an easy spot to sample multiple flavors without committing to a full pizza of just one variety.
Food Highlights
-
PRH Pizza: Built on a white garlic sauce base with mozzarella, ricotta, and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese blended together for a rich, creamy finish, the PRH Pizza is one of the most frequently ordered specialty pies and a favorite among regulars who love a cheese-forward slice.
-
Vodka Roni Pizza: Featuring a creamy vodka sauce base loaded with pepperoni and a blend of mozzarella and Parmigiano Reggiano, the Vodka Roni Pizza has earned a loyal following among diners who love the tangy, slightly spicy kick the vodka sauce brings to a classic pepperoni pie.
-
The Dude Pizza: Made with a house white garlic sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, the The Dude Pizza gives guests another rich, garlicky option for anyone who prefers their pizza without red sauce.
-
Cheezus Pizza: Kept simple with red sauce, mozzarella, and a dusting of Parmigiano Reggiano, the Cheezus Pizza lets the quality of the crust and cheese shine through without any distracting extra toppings.
-
Margherita Pizza: Topped with red sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, the Margherita Pizza remains a go-to for anyone who wants a lighter, classic Italian-style slice.
-
Classic Hawaiian Pizza: Bringing the familiar combination of sweet and savory toppings to both the New York and Detroit crust styles, the Classic Hawaiian Pizza gives fans of the polarizing classic a reliable, well-executed version to try here.
-
Detroit Style Pepperoni: Baked in a pan until the cheese caramelizes along the crispy edges while the crumb underneath stays soft and airy, the Detroit Style Pepperoni has been called the best in town by longtime Modesto pizza fans comparing it against other local spots.
Atmosphere
Sacred Slice built its early reputation from a food truck setup shared with other vendors in a Downtown Modesto lot, giving it a casual, communal feel where customers could grab a slice and mingle nearby food trucks while waiting.
With the move to a storefront on 15th Street, the experience has expanded into a more traditional sit-down setup while keeping that same laid-back, no-frills energy that built its following in the first place.
The addition of beer and wine to the new location gives visitors a reason to linger a little longer than they could at the truck, turning a quick slice stop into more of a full dining experience.
Regulars who followed the truck from its early days have embraced the new space, treating it as a natural next step for a business that earned its spot through consistently great pizza.
Bottomline
Sacred Slice is the Modesto pizza spot to hit when you want proof that some of the best pies in the valley started out of a food truck, whether that’s through the crowd-favorite PRH Pizza or the caramelized Detroit Style Pepperoni.
With two distinct crust styles, a devoted local following, and a brand-new storefront to match the hype, it’s easily one of downtown Modesto’s most exciting pizza destinations.
Address:
722 I St, Modesto, CA 95354
📞 +1 209-678-8080
🕔 Open Tue–Fri 11 AM–2 PM & 5–9 PM; Sat 1–7 PM (Closed Sun–Mon)